Cover Page

To Elisabeth, Amandine, Xavier and Maxime

Human Exposure to Electromagnetic Fields

From Extremely Low Frequency (ELF) to Radiofrequency

Patrick Staebler

images

Preface

“Knowledge is the only treasure that increases when shared”.

The laws of physics dictate that, whether we like it or not, we are all exposed to electric, magnetic and electromagnetic fields produced by the simple fact of using electricity. The number of electronic devices that radiate such fields has not stopped growing since the end of the 19th Century, when the first wireless communication took place and the spread of electricity began.

These devices have radically changed our lifestyle. They provide comfort, make tasks easier and offer opportunities for medical diagnosis and therapy. They have also deeply changed the way we communicate. Every proposed remote service must exist independently. In order to avoid interference between them, each one has its own frequency, so the radiation extends across the entire frequency spectrum.

This spectrum is a limited and fully regulated resource, the property of the states which grant its use. It will be increasingly busy around the clock. There will be no idle frequency, since future transmissions will dynamically manage the spectrum due to the arrival of software-defined radio providing ever more services. This means a higher data rate, and therefore more occupied frequencies.

Furthermore, the number of transmitters and receivers will continue to increase at a sustained rate. In addition to what are considered basic functions today (voice calls, internet and mobile video, contactless transactions, remote control), telephones will include Internet of Things (IoT) functions and others yet to be invented. The greater obstacles will be standardization and the protection of privacy, rather than technology.

We are eager for new technologies, despite the questions they raise for some people regarding the electromagnetic fields they radiate. These questions are logical because these fields are undetectable and intangible, so, for most of us, they remain a mystery.

Society’s concerns with radiation reappear with each technological advance, including the wireless telegraph in the 1930s, the television in the 1960s and the mass usage of wireless telecommunications since the beginning of the 1990s. The debate about power lines appeared belatedly at the end of the 1970s.

Nevertheless, these fields can be dangerous to health and safety if they are of high intensity. The harmful effects have been universally recognized for decades, but the possible effects on health after long-term exposure to low levels continue to be the subject of controversial debates.

Exposure to electromagnetic fields is a complex domain since, on the one hand, the relevant physical quantities are abstract, and, on the other, it is a multidisciplinary topic, given the interactions with biological systems. Physics, biology, medicine and metrology coexist.

In daily life, the general population is exposed to rather weak electromagnetic fields. The fields are stronger in occupational environments. Electrochemical processes, magnetic induction, welding, electricity distribution and telecommunications all expose workers to high field levels when they are close to the sources of radiation.

To protect workers and the public, limits were established. They have become a part of legislation.

There is a lot of confusion between electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields. This confusion extends to biophysical, biological and health effects. Moreover, certain publications use these terms incorrectly. There is also a lack of knowledge about sources of radiation. Few people know how exposure limits are determined, what precautions should be taken to carry out radiation measurements and, even less so, how these measurements and limits should be compared. Forming your own opinion in this domain requires at least some curiosity and an interest in science.

In addition, legislation requires that employers protect their employees from strong electromagnetic fields and that manufacturers produce compliant products that only radiate a limited amount or else provide use restrictions.

Intended audience

This book is intended for anyone who wishes to acquire a first level of knowledge about electromagnetic fields from 0 Hz to 300 GHz. Reading this book requires some scientific background. It contains several examples to facilitate understanding. The reader will be able to argue and discuss this controversial topic and analyze publications with a critical eye.

This book is also aimed at people who are responsible for the prevention of electromagnetic risk, such as engineers or technicians in charge of work conditions, health physicians, and, in particular, occupational doctors and trainers.

People in charge of ensuring compliance with regulations intended for the public and/or employees will have guidance on how to proceed and on metrology.

Manufacturers of household or professional materials will find elements to guide them in both the design (reduction and elimination of radiation at the source) and the production of an operating manual containing exposure data.

Finally, teachers can draw on several concrete applications to illustrate their lectures.

Disclaimer

This work is a summary of directives, recommendations, guides, standards and other official or scientific publications related to human exposure to electromagnetic fields. Most of these documents are references. In the event that the proposed reformulations are misunderstood, it is best to refer back to the original documents.

We have gone to great lengths to ensure that the content of this work is exhaustive and thorough. However, if our readers notice any errors, we would be grateful if they could communicate them so that subsequent editions can be corrected.

Organization and use of this book

This book summarizes all aspects of human exposure to electromagnetic fields from extremely low frequency (ELF) to radiofrequency or, to be more precise, from 0 Hz to 300 GHz. It allows the reader to form an opinion on the subject and adhere to regulations knowingly. This work is the result of several years of experience including presentations, standardizations, compliance assessments, measuring and designing equipment which radiates as low as reasonably achievable (www.exposition-cem.com).

images

Figure 1. Structure of the book

The content is structured as presented in Figure 1. There are nine chapters and two appendices, although some of these topics deserve a completely separate book. The main terms introduced can be found in the glossary.

Chapter 1: This chapter aims to introduce electromagnetism. This chapter, like those that follow, focuses on “human exposure”. Electric, magnetic and electromagnetic fields are explained by the laws of physics. They interact with organisms according to their nature and produce biological effects. It is essential to specify and clarify the vocabulary and definitions to avoid any misunderstanding. The relevant physical quantities are explained because they determine the effects and measurements. They also make it possible to define the exposure limit values. Although the frequencies extend infinitely, the “electromagnetic field” perimeter, as defined, is limited. This aspect has to be clarified. This chapter is fundamental because it is the gateway to grasping the human exposure concepts. For some, this chapter is a refresher for distant studies, but it should be approachable for those who have some gaps in their physical science backgrounds. Understanding this chapter is essential to take full advantage of this book.

Chapter 2: This chapter presents radiation sources encountered in daily life, others which are present in the workplace as well as others which are used for diagnostic or therapeutic purposes. It is impossible to be exhaustive because the sources are so numerous and heterogeneous.

Chapter 3: This chapter describes biophysical mechanisms. How do fields interact with material, in particular with biological tissue? This chapter explains why these tissues do not have the same electric properties as most materials used in electrical engineering. This chapter also takes a macroscopic approach. It describes how fields penetrate the human body and how they behave according to their nature and frequency.

Chapter 4: This chapter discusses the biological effects of fields, as well as the sensory and health effects. When the fields are intense, they can disturb certain senses or be imperceptibly harmful to health. This chapter presents the recognized acute effects as well as a summary of the studies on chronic (long term) effects. Direct effects are distinguished from indirect effects. The definitions are recalled to avoid confusion.

Chapter 5: Exposure limits (basic restrictions, reference level, etc.) logically follow biological effects. These limits were established to prevent adverse effects on health and well-being. This chapter also justifies the distinction between exposure of the general public and workers. It explains how these limits are determined. The values are summarized and illustrated in order to be quickly interpreted and compared. This chapter also considers people or workers at particular risk.

Chapter 6: This chapter explains the methods of comparison between measured or calculated fields and limit values, especially when these fields have complex waveforms. These methods are as significant as the limit values when assessing an exposure situation. In particular, the weighted peak method used to assess low-frequency exposure is introduced. Necessarily, this chapter includes many formulas. They may seem complex, but in reality most of them are comprehensible even to those readers who have some mathematical gaps.

Chapter 7: This chapter supports the previous one with examples of theoretical and real applications. Understanding them makes it possible to become familiar with the calculation methods presented. It can be read subsequently.

Chapter 8: This chapter introduces the basics of exposure assessment. Measuring techniques for electric, magnetic and electromagnetic fields are presented. Operating precautions and specific sources of uncertainty about the nature of these fields are explained. Measurement of contact and induced electric currents is also introduced.

The last section in this chapter succinctly approaches dosimetry, a technique used to precisely assess exposures when required or when measuring becomes impossible for physical reasons as indicated throughout this book.

Chapter 9: This chapter situates Directive 2013/35/EU (electromagnetic fields) in the European context and reformulates it by giving some practical guidance for its implementation. It refers to Appendix 1, which classifies equipment according to its radiation intensity. This chapter helps readers understand the interest of the exposure system limits presented in Chapter 5, which could seem obscure at the first reading.

Appendix 1 sorts equipment and workplaces according to the electromagnetic field strength to which the workers may be exposed. This appendix supports Chapter 9.

Appendix 2 presents the weighting functions implemented to assess exposure according to the calculation technique using the weighted peak method. This appendix complements Chapters 6 and 7.

Enjoy.

Patrick STAEBLER
March 2017

Acknowledgments

The domain of human exposure to electromagnetic fields is very active, with many talented individuals working within it. This book was made possible because of lasting exchanges with:

who share their knowledge with such enthusiasm. I am grateful to all of them.

I express my sincere gratitude to Alain Azoulay (Honorary Professor at Supélec) who encouraged me to get into this project and who supported me in moments of doubt. Alain proofread this book before it was even a full draft.

I would also like to thank my friendly and generous colleagues who took the time to proofread chapters of this book related to their area of excellence: Dr. Martine Souques, François Deschamps, Thierry Letertre (teacher-researcher at the CentraleSupélec engineering school) and Péniamin Matossian (expert in electromagnetic compatibility).

I would also like to thank my friend Eric Lanzi, who volunteered to proofread this work. He provided many relevant comments driven by his own scientific curiosity and his love of new technologies.

Thank you to my wife, Elisabeth, who had the huge task of being my first reader, and to my son, Xavier, who verified the coherence of these chapters with a fresh outlook on the domain of electromagnetic fields.

Finally, I cannot end without thanking my colleagues at the Société française de radioprotection, section Rayonnement non ionisant (SFRP-RNI) [Radiation Protection Society of France, Non-Ionizing Radiation section] and my colleagues on standardization committees, who provided me with many helpful clarifications.