and
Ninth Edition
This edition first published 2017
© 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Edition history: Thomas Y. Crowell Company (1e, 1949; 2e, 1955; 2re, 1960; 3e, 1966);
Harlan Davidson, Inc. (4e, 1984; 5e, 1993; 6e, 1999; 7e, 2004; 8e, 2010)
Registered Office
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, UK
Editorial Offices
350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148-5020, USA
9600 Garsington Road, Oxford, OX4 2DQ, UK
The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, UK
For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services, and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com/wiley-blackwell.
The right of Melvyn Dubofsky and Joseph A. McCartin to be identified as the authors of this work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher.
Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books.
Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book.
Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and authors have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services and neither the publisher nor the authors shall be liable for damages arising herefrom. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Dubofsky, Melvyn, 1934- author. | McCartin, Joseph Anthony, author.
Title: Labor in America : a history / Melvyn Dubofsky and Joseph A. McCartin.
Description: 9th edition. | Hoboken, NJ : John Wiley & Sons, [2017] | Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2016043343| ISBN 9781118976845 (cloth) | ISBN 9781118976852 (pbk.)
Subjects: LCSH: Labor–United States–History. | Working class–United States–History. | Labor unions–United States–History.
Classification: LCC HD8066 .D8 2017 | DDC 331.880973–dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016043343
Cover images: kledge/Getty Images, Inc.; Granger, NYC/The Granger Collection
1.1 | Certificate of indenture, 1767 |
1.2 | An African American servant at work tending to a white master |
2.1 | Notice of a mechanics' meeting, 1774 |
2.2 | Mechanics' Association membership certificate, 1800 |
3.1 | Ship carpenter at work, 1807 |
3.2 | “By Hammer and Hand All Arts Do Stand.” |
4.1 | Bricklayers' bill of prices, 1814 |
4.2 | Ely Moore, leader of the General Trades' Union and the National Trades' Union |
5.1 | Women shoe workers from Lynn, Massachusetts, striking for better wages, 1860 |
5.2 | Lowell, Massachusetts, a model mill town |
6.1 | William Sylvis, president of the National Labor Union |
7.1 | Labor Day parade, New York City, September 5, 1882 |
7.2 | Men and women harass a “blackleg” strikebreaker during a coal miners' strike in Ohio, 1880s |
8.1 | Founders of the Knights of Labor depicted holding a portrait of their organization's first leader, Uriah S. Stephens |
8.2 | Terence V. Powderly, leader of the Knights of Labor |
8.3 | Terence Powderly and Frank J. Farrell at the tenth annual convention of the Knights of Labor, 1886 |
9.1 | Samuel Gompers, first leader of the American Federation of Labor, 1886 |
10.1 | The Battle of Homestead, 1892 |
11.1 | United Mine Workers membership certificate, 1890s |
11.2 | President Woodrow Wilson, Samuel Gompers, and William B. Wilson, 1916 |
12.1 | Eugene V. Debs, Socialist Party leader |
12.2 | Members of the Massachusetts state militia keep strikers away from the mills during the Lawrence textile strike, 1912 |
12.3 | IWW leaders: William D. “Big Bill” Haywood, Elizabeth Gurley Flynn, and Carlo Tresca |
12.4 | A sample of IWW propaganda stickers |
13.1 | Samuel Gompers in a World War I propaganda picture, circa 1918 |
13.2 | Mary Harris “Mother” Jones, a legendary labor activist, and William Z. Foster, leader of Communist Party |
14.1 | A 1920s poster from the Goodyear Company |
15.1 | Robert Fechner, director of the Civil Conservation Corps (CCC), President Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Henry Wallace, US secretary of agriculture, with formerly unemployed CCC workers |
16.1 | CIO founders Sidney Hillman, John L. Lewis, and Philip Murray, 1937 |
16.2 | Sit-down strikers hanging effigies from the windows of Fisher Body Plant No. 2 in Flint, Michigan, January 1937 |
16.3 | Organizers Richard Frankenstein and Walter Reuther after being beaten by Ford servicemen while trying to hand out union circulars at the Dearborn plant, May 26, 1937 |
17.1 | Sidney Hillman, president of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers of America |
18.1 | Women at work on an assembly line, Douglas Aircraft bomber plant, Long Beach, California |
18.2 | American labor supports the war effort: Philip Murray of the CIO and William Green of the AFL |
19.1 | John L. Lewis surveys the damage after a mine disaster in West Frankfurt, Illinois |
19.2 | George Meany and Walter Reuther clasping hands at the merger of the AFL and CIO |
20.1 | Teamster leaders James R. Hoffa and Frank Fitzsimmons, 1966 |
20.2 | Cesar Chavez, the first successful organizer of farmworkers |
20.3 | Chavez's union colleague, Dolores Huerta, signaling workers to strike, near Delano, California |
21.1 | A solidarity rally for PATCO strikers, Houston, Texas, 1981 |
21.2 | Lane Kirkland, president of the AFL-CIO, at Dartmouth College, 1982 |
22.1 | John Sweeney, of the Service Employees International Union |
22.2 | Linda Chavez-Thompson, of the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees |
22.3 | Manuel Morales marching in a massive May Day march in downtown Los Angeles, May 1, 2006 |
22.4 | Andy Stern, SEIU president, 2009 |
23.1 | Members of the United Automobile Workers in Canton, Michigan, 2009 |
23.2 | President Barack Obama addresses the AFL-CIO, 2009 |
23.3 | AFL-CIO leaders Richard Trumka, Liz Shuler, and Tefere Gebre |
23.4 | Mary Kay Henry, Service Employees International Union president, with members of her union, 2015 |
23.5 | A “Fight for 15” demonstration in Kansas City, Missouri, 2015 |
AA | Amalgamated Association of Iron, Steel, and Tin Workers |
ACA | Affordable Care Act |
ACTWU | Amalgamated Clothing and Textile Workers Union |
ACWA | Amalgamated Clothing Workers of America |
AFL | American Federation of Labor |
AFSCME | American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees |
AFT | American Federation of Teachers |
ALA | Alliance for Labor Action |
ARU | American Railway Union |
BCTGM | Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers International Union |
BSCP | Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters |
CIO | Committee for Industrial Organization/Congress of Industrial Organizations |
CMIU | Cigar Makers' International Union |
COPE | Committee on Political Education |
CPUSA | Communist Party of America |
CtW | Change to Win |
DLC | Democratic Leadership Council |
EFCA | Employee Free Choice Act |
EITC | Earned Income Tax Credit |
EMOs | education management organizations |
FEPC | Fair Employment Practices Commission |
GATT | General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade |
GM | General Motors |
IAM | International Association of Machinists |
ICFTU | International Confederation of Free Trade Unions |
ILGWU | International Ladies' Garment Workers' Union |
ILWU | International Longshore and Warehouse Union |
IWW | Industrial Workers of the World |
NAFTA | North American Free Trade Agreement |
NAM | National Association of Manufacturers |
NATO | North Atlantic Treaty Organization |
NCF | National Civic Federation |
NDLON | National Day Laborers Organizing Network |
NDMB | National Defense Mediation Board |
NDWA | National Domestic Workers Alliance |
NLRB | National Labor Relations Board |
NLU | National Labor Union |
NRA | National Recovery Administration |
NTWA | National Taxi Workers Alliance |
NUHW | National Union of Healthcare Workers |
NWGA | National Guest Workers Alliance |
NWLB | National War Labor Board |
OECD | Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development |
OPEC | Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries |
OUR Walmart | Organization United for Respect at Walmart |
PAC | Political Action Committee |
PATCO | Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization |
SEIU | Service Employees International Union |
SEIU-UHW | United Healthcare Workers West |
SPA | Socialist Party of America |
SWOC | Steel Workers' Organizing Committee |
TDU | Teamsters for a Democratic Union |
TPP | Trans-Pacific Partnership |
TSA | Transportation Security Administration |
TTIP | Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership |
TUUL | Trade Union Unity League |
UAW | United Automobile Workers |
UBC | United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners |
UFCW | United Food and Commercial Workers International Union |
UFW | United Farm Workers of America |
UMW | United Mine Workers |
UNITE | Union of Needletrades, Industrial and Textile Employees |
UPS | United Parcel Service |
USAS | United Students Against Sweatshops |
USW | United Steelworkers of America |
WFM | Western Federation of Miners |
WTO | World Trade Organization |
We would like to thank Andrew Davidson and Philip Thomas for their careful editing of the text, our research assistant Alyssa Russell for gathering new photographs and permissions, and Julia Kirk, Allison Kostka, James Schultz, and Fiona Screen of Wiley for their work in bringing the ninth edition to press.
The contours and content of this book have evolved in response to the experiences of American workers and their organizations as they have played out over the course of the last 70 years. When Foster Rhea Dulles began drafting the first edition of this textbook after World War II, the American labor movement was ascendant, benefiting from a surge of organizing which had unionized mass production industries. With nearly one-third of the nation's workers in unions, workers experiencing unprecedented improvements in their living standards, and organized labor emerging as a powerful political influence, many believed that the country was entering what the leading labor economist of the time, Sumner H. Slichter, called a “laboristic age.” By the time the first edition of Dulles's book was published in 1949, such boundless optimism was already tempered by the onset of the Cold War and an equally hardnosed war of position between employers and unions in the postwar era. Yet the fact that labor drew the interest of Dulles, whose first books dealt with the history of the US in the Pacific, indicated an important shift in scholarly attention to the history of workers and their movement. Up to that point, labor history was still largely the province of labor economists who had followed in the footsteps of John R. Commons. Few trained historians had embraced the subject before Dulles began this textbook, which he revised twice before his death in 1970.
By the time Melvyn Dubofsky began his first revision of the text for the fourth edition in 1980, both the nature of labor history scholarship and the condition of labor in America had changed markedly. Scholarship was blossoming as the “New Labor History” attracted a generation of historians who sought to break from the institutional focus on trade unionism and collective bargaining characteristic of the Commons school. Influenced by the intellectual and political currents of the 1960s, this generation set out to discover the history of the American working class in all of its diversity. These scholars did their job so well that it became difficult to craft a unitary synthesis of US labor history that took account of all of their findings.
But even as this new scholarship poured forth, the union movement was entering a period of crisis from which it has yet to emerge. Union membership and the practice of collective bargaining had been temporarily buoyed by the organization of public sector workers in the 1960 and 1970s. However, during the fiscal crisis of the 1970s, the expansion of public sector organization halted and the nation first encountered a series of economic, social, and political developments that were to undermine union strength in the years to come. Dubofsky's first edition of this text appeared in 1984, and coincided with President Ronald Reagan's landslide reelection. The only former union president to win the nation's highest office, Reagan's administration and the antilabor policies it promoted ironically came to symbolize the breakdown of a once broad and bipartisan support for collective bargaining that had held sway in the years since World War II. As Dubofsky continued to revise this text over the last thirty years, globalization, financialization, increased antiunionism, and the rise of neoliberal economic policy accelerated the breakdown of the labor relations model that was just taking shape when Dulles began his work.
As Joseph McCartin joins this enterprise, it seems clear that American labor history is entering a new and as yet uncharted era. Over the past forty years, world capitalism has undergone an enormous transformation with huge implications for American workers. Globalization has tied the fates of workers around the world to each other as never before. New models of corporate structure and employment, driven by technological innovations and the power of financial markets, are remaking the nature of the firm and of workers' relationships to their work and their employer. Workers and labor movements everywhere have struggled to find their footing in this new world, and arguably none have struggled more than the American labor movement, whose story is chronicled in these pages.
The arrival of the Great Recession in 2008 punctuated the turn into this new epoch. The last edition of this text came out in the midst of that recession. Although the Great Recession has now passed, it has left social upheaval and an increased sense of economic and political insecurity in its wake, developments that have led to the surprising election of Donald J. Trump to the presidency. It seems clear that a new era is dawning, one that resembles that of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries in its implications for workers. As in that earlier time, work is being reorganized in ways that undermine solidarity, unions are in retreat, inequality is surging, and there seems to be little hope in the near term for the enactment of national policies that would bring more stability and justice to the lives of workers, let alone empower them to have more say over their working lives and the direction of the economy. Yet, as in that earlier time, public unease with the concentration of power and wealth is growing and creative ideas are percolating through the ranks of workers and worker organizations. As the twentieth-century model of union organization, government regulation, and welfare state support breaks down, unions have begun developing unprecedented forms of international cooperation, and new kinds of worker organization that some have taken to calling “alt-labor” have begun to emerge. Whether this creativity foretells a twenty-first-century revival of worker organization is as yet unclear. In this volume we seek to put these new developments in historical perspective.
This text focuses, as previous editions have, on the history of workers' collective responses to the conditions of working life that they have faced over more than two centuries. It does not aspire to be a history of the American working-class experience as such. In one volume we cannot evoke the full variety of that experience, or fully limn the polyglot complexities of working-class culture and consciousness. Nor is this volume written in the framework of the “history of capitalism” that has become a recent focus of scholars – although, to be sure, it draws insights from that scholarship. While the history of capitalism provides a necessary context for understanding American workers and US labor history, the story of workers' responses to capitalism's development constitutes its own tale and requires its own stage, for it is a long, rich, and complex story. As a world takes shape around us in which workers' ability to act collectively to influence their futures seems more enfeebled than it has been in a century, it is also a history that demands deepened understanding and refreshed remembrance – now more than ever. In that spirit we commend this work to you.
November 15, 2016
Melvyn Dubofsky
Joseph A. McCartin