jpg

The Roman Empire in Context

The Ancient World: Comparative Histories

Series Editor: Kurt A. Raaflaub


Published

War and Peace in the Ancient World
Edited by Kurt A. Raaflaub

Household and Family Religion in Antiquity
Edited by John Bodel and Saul Olyan

Geography and Ethnography: Perceptions of the World in Pre-Modern Societies
Edited by Kurt A. Raaflaub and Richard J. A. Talbert

Epic and History
Edited by David Konstan and Kurt A. Raaflaub

The Roman Empire in Context: Historical and Comparative Perspectives
Edited by Johann P. Arnason and Kurt A. Raaflaub


In preparation

Highways and Byways in the Ancient World
Edited by Susan Alcock, John Bodel, and Richard Talbert

Thinking, Recording, and Writing History in the Ancient World
Edited by Kurt A. Raaflaub

Image

Editors and contributors dedicate
this volume to the memory of
S. N. Eisenstadt
(Sept. 10, 1923–Sept. 2, 2010)

Contents

Notes on Contributors

Series Editor’s Preface

1 Introduction
Johann P. Arnason

Part I Expansion and Transformation

2 From City-State to Empire: Rome in Comparative Perspective
Kurt A. Raaflaub

3 The Transition from Republic to Principate: Loss of Legitimacy, Revolution, and Acceptance
Egon Flaig

4 Strong and Weak Regimes: Comparing the Roman Principate and the Medieval Crown of Aragon
D. A. Cohen and J. E. Lendon

Part II Late Antiquity: Division, Transformation, and Continuity

5 The Background to the Third-Century Crisis of the Roman
Empire
Adam Ziolkowski

6 The End of Sacrifice: Religious Mutations of Late Antiquity
Guy G. Stroumsa

7 Contextualizing Late Antiquity: The First Millennium
Garth Fowden

Part III Destinies of the Roman Legacy

8 The Franks: Rome’s Heirs in the West
Matthias Becher

9 The End of Rome? The Transformation of the Eastern Empire in the Seventh and Eighth Centuries CE
John Haldon

10 The First Islamic Empire
Chase F. Robinson

Part IV Comparative Perspectives

11 From City-State to Empire: The Case of Assyria
Mario Liverani

12 China’s Early Empires: The Authority and Means of Government
Michael Loewe

13 The Legs of the Throne: Kings, Elites, and Subjects in Sasanian Iran
Scott McDonough

14 The King of Kings: Universal Hegemony, Imperial Power, and a New Comparative History of Rome
Peter Fibiger Bang

Part V Conceptual and Theoretical Reflections

15 The Roman Phenomenon: State, Empire, and Civilization
Johann P. Arnason

16 Roman–European Continuities: Conceptual and Historical
Questions
Peter Wagner

General Index

Index of Sources (selective)

Notes on Contributors


Johann P. Arnason took his doctoral degree at the University of Frankfurt and later taught sociology at La Trobe University in Melbourne, where he is now Emeritus Professor. He is also Visiting Professor at the Charles University in Prague. His research has focused on historical sociology, with growing emphasis on the comparative analysis of civilizations. Recent publications include Civilizations in Dispute: Historical Questions and Theoretical Traditions (2003); Axial Civilizations and World History (co-edited, 2005); Eurasian Transformations, 10th to 13th Centuries: Crystallizations, Divergences, Renaissances (co-edited, 2005), and Domains and Divisions of European History (co-edited, 2010).


Peter Fibiger Bang holds a PhD from Cambridge and is an Associate Professor of Roman History in the Saxo Institute, University of Copenhagen. His research has focused on the political economy of the Roman Empire, new comparative perspectives on the Greco-Roman world, state-formation, and the character of patrimonial power in tributary empires. In 2005–9 he was chair of a European research network dedicated to historical comparisons of the Roman, Mughal, and Ottoman empires. Besides edited volumes and articles, his publications include The Roman Bazaar: A Comparative Study of Trade and Markets in a Tributary Empire (2008). He is currently working on The Oxford Handbook of the Ancient State (co-edited, forthcoming).


Matthias Becher is Professor of Medieval History at the University of Bonn. He took his PhD at the University of Konstanz (1990) and his Habilitation at the University of Paderborn (1995). One of his main areas of research is the history of the Frankish kingdoms. He is author of Eid und Herrschaft. Untersuchungen zum Herrscherethos Karls des Großen (1993); Rex, Dux und Gens. Untersuchungen zur Entstehung des sächsischen Herzogtums im 9. und 10. Jahrhundert (1996); Karl der Große (1999; English translation, Charlemagne, 2003); and Merowinger und Karolinger (2009).


David A. Cohen, an historian of medieval Spain, has his degrees from Yale University and teaches history at Assumption College in Worcester, Massachusetts.


Egon Flaig has a PhD from the Freie Universität Berlin and Habilitation from the University of Freiburg im Breisgau. He is Professor of Ancient History at the University of Rostock. His main scholarly interests include the constitution of social norms in ancient societies, procedures to take collective decisions and the emergence of majority rule (on which he is currently completing a monograph), semiotic and ritual dimensions of ancient politics, slavery in comparative perspective, equality and inequality in political thought, and theocratic and anthroponomic foundations of political order. Some of his publications that are relevant to the present subject are Den Kaiser herausfordern. Die Usurpation im Römischen Reich (1992); “Entscheidung und Konsens. Zu den Feldern der politischen Kommunikation zwischen Aristokratie und Plebs,” in M. Jehne (ed.), Demokratie in Rom? Die Rolle des Volkes in der Politik der römischen Republik, 77–127 (1995); and Ritualisierte Politik. Zeichen, Gesten und Herrschaft im Alten Rom (2003).


Garth Fowden is a Research Professor at the Center for Greek and Roman Antiquity, National Research Foundation, Athens. His principal interest is in the intellectual history of the Graeco-Arabic world. He has published The Egyptian Hermes: A Historical Approach to the Late Pagan Mind (1986; corr. repr. with new pref., 1993); Empire to Commonwealth: Consequences of Monotheism in Late Antiquity (1993); Qusayr ‘Amra: Art and the Umayyad Elite in Late Antique Syria (2004); and chapters in the new edition of The Cambridge Ancient History, vols. XII and XIII.


John Haldon is Professor of History at Princeton University. He studied in the UK, Greece, and Germany, and currently is a Senior Fellow at the Dumbarton Oaks Center for Byzantine Studies in Washington, DC. His research focuses on the history of the early and middle Byzantine Empire, in particular the period from the seventh to the eleventh centuries; on state systems and structures across the European and Islamic worlds from late ancient to early modern times; and on the production, distribution, and consumption of resources in the late ancient and medieval world, especially in the context of warfare. His publications include Byzantium in the Seventh Century (1990/1997); Three Treatises on Byzantine Imperial Military Expeditions (1990); The State and the Tributary Mode of Production (1993); Warfare, State, and Society in Byzantium (1999); Byzantium: A History (2000); and The Palgrave Atlas of Byzantine History (2006).


J. E. Lendon has a PhD from Yale University and is Professor of History in the Corcoran Department of History at the University of Virginia. He held a Junior Fellowship at the Center for Hellenic Studies in Washington, DC, and an Alexander von Humboldt Research Fellowship in Germany. His interests focus on Greek and Roman foreign affairs and warfare. He is author of Empire of Honor: The Art of Government in the Roman World (1997) and Soldiers and Ghosts: A History of Battle in Classical Antiquity (2005, trans. into Italian and Spanish).


Mario Liverani is Professor of the History of the Ancient Near East at the University of Rome “La Sapienza.” He is honorary member of the American Oriental Society, member of the “Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei,” and of the “Academia Europaea,” and holds honorary degrees from the Universities of Copenhagen and Madrid (Autonoma). He has excavated in Syria, Turkey, and Libya. His main research interests include the Assyrian Empire, Mesopotamian historiography, the Levant in the Amarna letters, and the ancient “oriental” city. Recent monographs include International Relations in the Ancient Near East (2001); Myth and Politics in Ancient Near Eastern Historiography (2004); Israel’s History and the History of Israel (2005); and Uruk: The First City (2006).


Michael Loewe received his PhD from the University of London. He was University Lecturer in Chinese Studies and Fellow of Clare Hall at the University of Cambridge until his retirement in 1990. He has held various visiting professorships and is, among other distinctions, Foreign Honorary Member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. His publications include Divination, Mythology, and Monarchy in Han China (1994); A Biographical Dictionary of the Qin, Han, and Xin Dynasties (2000), with a Companion: The Men Who Governed Han China (2004); and The Government of the Qin and Han Empires 221 BCE 220 CE (2006). Among his several edited volumes is vol. I of The Cambridge History of China (1986).


Scott McDonough is an Assistant Professor of History at the William Paterson University of New Jersey. He received his PhD in History from the University of California, Los Angeles (2005). His research interests lie in the social, institutional, and religious history of late ancient West Asia, especially pre-Islamic Iran. Recent articles include “A Second Constantine? The Sasanian King Yazdgard I in Christian History and Historiography” and “A Question of Faith? Persecution and Political Centralization in the Sasanian Empire of Yazdgard II (438–457 CE).” He is currently completing a monograph: “We Pray for Our Glorious King”: Power, Piety, and Patronage in Sasanian Iran, 220–651 CE.


Kurt A. Raaflaub received his PhD from the University of Basel. He is David Herlihy University Professor and Professor of Classics and History Emeritus at Brown University, where he was also Director of the Program in Ancient Studies. His research interests focus on the social, political, and intellectual history of archaic Greece and the Roman republic, war and peace in the ancient world, and the comparative history of the ancient world. Recent publications include The Discovery of Freedom in Ancient Greece (2004, winner of the American Historical Association’s James Henry Breasted Prize); War and Peace in the Ancient World (edited, 2007); Origins of Democracy in Ancient Greece (co-author, 2007); A Companion to Archaic Greece (co-edited, 2009); Epic and History (co-edited, 2010).


Chase F. Robinson was Professor of Islamic History in the Faculty of Oriental Studies at Oxford University and is now Provost and Distinguished Professor of History at the Graduate Center, the City University of New York. He received his PhD from Harvard University. His main research areas are early Islamic history and historiography. His recent publications include Empire and Elites after the Muslim Conquest: The Transformation of Northern Mesopotamia (2000); A Medieval Islamic City Reconsidered: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Samarra (edited, 2001); Islamic Historiography (2003); ‘Abd al-Malik (2005).


Guy G. Stroumsa has a PhD from Harvard University and is Professor of the Study of the Abrahamic Religions and Fellow of Lady Margaret Hall at Oxford University, and Martin Buber Professor of Comparative Religion Emeritus at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. His current main research interests lie in the shaping of the Abrahamic religions in late antiquity and in the oriental traditions of wisdom in late antiquity. Recent publications include The End of Sacrifice: The Religious Transformations of Late Antiquity (2009), and A New Science: The Discovery of Religion in the Age of Reason (2010).


Peter Wagner received his PhD from the Freie Universität of Berlin. He has recently been appointed ICREA Research Professor at the University of Barcelona. His main research interests are in social and political theory and in comparative historical sociology. In the latter area, he has had a particular interest in the long-run historical trajectories of societies. His recent book publications include Modernity as Experience and Interpretation (2008) and Varieties of World-Making: Beyond Globalization (co-edited, 2007).


Adam Ziolkowski was educated at the University of Warsaw, where he also got his PhD and Habilitation and is now Professor of Ancient History. His research interests include early Rome, the social and economic history of the republic, the topography of the city of Rome in antiquity, Roman imperialism, and early Christianity. He is the author, among other works, of Sacra Via Twenty Years After (2004) and Storia di Roma (2000).


Series Editor’s Preface

The Ancient World: Comparative Histories

The application of a comparative approach to the ancient world at large has been rare. This series, of which the current volume is the fifth, intends to fill this gap. It pursues important social, political, religious, economic, and intellectual issues through a wide range of ancient or early societies, occasionally covering an even broader diachronic scope. “Ancient” will here be understood broadly, encompassing not only societies that are “ancient” within the traditional chronological framework of c.3000 BCE to c.600 CE in East, South, and West Asia, the Mediterranean, and Europe, but also later ones that are structurally “ancient” or “early,” such as those in premodern Japan or in Meso- and South America before the Spanish Conquest. By engaging in comparative studies of the ancient world on a truly global scale, this series hopes to throw light not only on common patterns and marked differences, but also to illustrate the remarkable variety of responses humankind developed to meet common challenges. Focusing as it does on periods that are far removed from our own time, and in which modern identities are less immediately engaged, the series contributes to enhancing our understanding and appreciation of differences among cultures of various traditions and backgrounds. Not least, it thus illuminates the continuing relevance of the study of the ancient world in helping us to cope with problems of our own multicultural world.

Earlier volumes in the series are War and Peace in the Ancient World (ed. Kurt A. Raaflaub, 2007); Household and Family Religion in Antiquity (eds. John Bodel and Saul Olyan, 2008); Epic and History (eds. David Konstan and Kurt Raaflaub, 2010); Geography and Ethnography: Perceptions of the World in Premodern Societies (eds. Kurt Raaflaub and Richard Talbert, 2010). Other volumes are in preparation: Highways and Byways in the Ancient World (eds. Susan Alcock, John Bodel, and Richard Talbert); Thinking, Recording, and Writing History in the Ancient World (ed. Kurt A. Raaflaub).

The current volume has its origin in a colloquium held in 2005 at the European University Institute in Florence, organized by Peter Wagner, Johann Arnason, Bo Stråth, and Björn Wittrock. The papers given and discussed there in a stimulating atmosphere and under ideal conditions were later profoundly revised or rewritten and complemented by others that seemed needed to realize the concept and framework of this volume as they emerged during those discussions. I thank the Institute and the Swedish Collegium of Advanced Study in the Sciences for financial support and generous hospitality, the organizers of the colloquium for their efforts in starting this project, the contributors for their patient and productive collaboration, my fellow editor, Johann Arnason, for his inspiration and leadership, and Al Bertrand and his collaborators at Wiley-Blackwell for their enthusiastic support of this project and the entire series. Johann Arnason would like to thank the Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung for supporting a research stay at the University of Frankfurt/Main, during which his contributions to this volume were finalized. Both editors thank Jennifer Lewton Yates for compiling the two indices.

Kurt A. Raaflaub