Cover Page

THE U.S. HEALTHCARE SYSTEM

Origins, Organization and Opportunities

 

JOEL I. SHALOWITZ, MD, MBA

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wiley Logo

To Mervin Shalowitz, MD: father, teacher, colleague, and friend

LIST OF EXHIBITS

  1. 1.1 Examples of Mission Features for Healthcare Systems
  2. 1.2 Definition of System
  3. 1.3 Factors Influencing Healthcare Systems
  4. 1.4 Features of Healthcare Systems
  5. 1.5 Definition of Culture
  6. 1.6 Stakeholders
  7. 1.7 Strategic Choices to Deliver Healthcare Stakeholder Value
  8. 1.8 Components of Cost
  9. 1.9 Components of Quality
  10. 1.10 Components of Access/Equity
  11. 1.11 Comprehensive View of Stakeholder Value Proposition Components
  12. 2.1 Reasons Stakeholder Seek and Influence Care Decisions
  13. 2.2 Personal Characteristics That Influence Care-Seeking Behavior and Health Status
  14. 2.3 Total Personal Healthcare Spending (millions) by Gender and Age Group 2012
  15. 2.4 Healthcare Visits in the Past 12 Months Among Children Aged 2–17 and Adults Aged 18 and Over, by Age and Provider Type: United States, 1997, 2006, and 2015
  16. 2.5 Prescription Drug Use in the Past 30 days Among Adults Aged 18 and Over, by Age and Number of Drugs Taken: United States, 1988–1994 Through 2013–2014
  17. 2.6 U.S. Life Expectancy, by Race, Hispanic Origin, and Sex: 2006–2015
  18. 2.7 Income and Healthcare Utilization—Some International Examples
  19. 2.8 Effect of Education on Healthcare Utilization—Some International Examples
  20. 2.9 Effects of Culture and Beliefs on Healthcare Behavior
  21. 2.10 Some Multifactor Relationships in Healthcare Utilization
  22. 2.11 Some Actions Used to Reduce Demand for Healthcare
  23. 2.12 Average General Health Plan Deductibles for Single Coverage, 2006–2017
  24. 2.13 Percentage of Covered Workers Enrolled in a Plan with a High General Annual Deductible for Single Coverage, by Firm Size, 2017
  25. 2.14 Summary of Some Key Findings of the RAND Health Insurance Experiment
  26. 2.15 Examples of Cost-Saving Prevention
  27. 2.16 Profile of the Six Healthcare Consumer Segments
  28. 2.17 Use of Healthcare Facilities and Services versus Willingness to Experience Innovation
  29. 2.18 Provider-Induced Demand: Some U.S. Examples
  30. 2.19 Provider-Induced Demand: Some International Examples
  31. 2.20 Local Area Variations: International Examples
  32. 2.21 Variation in Number of Surgical Procedures Performed per 10,000 Persons for the 13 Vermont Hospital Service Areas and Comparison Populations, 1969
  33. 3.1 Scenarios for Measure Variations by Prevalence
  34. 3.2 Case Control Study Design
  35. 3.3 Case Control Study Matrix
  36. 3.4 Evidence That an Association Is More Likely Causal
  37. 3.5 Prospective Cohort Study
  38. 3.6 Retrospective Cohort Study
  39. 3.7 Relative Risk Calculation
  40. 3.8 Example of Results of a Heart Attack Outcome Study
  41. 3.9 Randomized Control Trial Study Design
  42. 4.1 Some Technologies That Consolidated Care in Hospitals
  43. 4.2 IRS Conditions Allowing Issuance of Tax-Exempt Hospital Debt
  44. 4.3 Examples of Legal Definitions of Hospitals
  45. 4.4 Percentage of U.S. Hospital Costs in 2016, by Type of Expense
  46. 4.5 Number of Registered Hospitals in the United States in 2016, by Number of Beds
  47. 4.6 Federal Spending on Graduate Medical Education Training, 2015
  48. 4.7 Sample Mission Statements of Teaching Hospitals
  49. 4.8 Number of Hospitals in the United States from 2009 to 2016, by Ownership Type
  50. 4.9 Exemption Requirements—Section 501(c)(3) Organizations
  51. 4.10 Hospital Activities to Preserve 501(c)(3) Status
  52. 4.11 Comparison of Criteria between Utah and Vermont Whether an Institution Is Using a Property “Exclusively…for Charitable Purposes”
  53. 4.12 Top 10 Diagnoses for LTCHs (2014)
  54. 4.13 Number of Nonprofit Hospital Systems in the United States from 1995 to 2016 Total Number of Hospitals in Systems: At least 3,200
  55. 4.14 Ten Largest U.S. Health Systems Based on Number of Hospitals (as of December 2017)
  56. 4.15 Types of Facilities Owned by Systems
  57. 4.16 Types of Programs Run by Systems
  58. 4.17 Example of Early Failure of Provider-Sponsored Health Insurance Plan
  59. 4.18 Services the Six Largest Group Purchasing Organizations (GPO) Reported Providing in 2008
  60. 4.19 Hypothetical Flow of Contract Administrative Fees
  61. 4.20 Share of Hospitals and Medicare Payments by Rural Hospital Type, 2015
  62. 4.21 Number of Faith-Based Hospitals in the United States from 1995 to 2016
  63. 4.22 Clinical Episodes for the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement Advanced Program—29 Inpatient Clinical Episodes
  64. 4.23 The Value Chain of Healthcare Delivery
  65. 4.24 Shared Savings Program ACO Participation Options
  66. 4.25 Savings and Losses of Risk-Based and No-Risk ACOs
  67. 4.26 Nonprofits and Sarbanes-Oxley
  68. 4.27 Medicare Conditions of Participation and Conditions for Coverage
  69. 5.1 The Four Humors (Elements)
  70. 5.2 Federal Spending on Graduate Medical Education Training, 2015
  71. 5.3 History of Medical Boards
  72. 5.4 Location Quotients of Physicians and Surgeons, All Other, by State. May 2017
  73. 5.5 Annual Compensation Earned by U.S. Physicians as of 2018, by Specialty (in 1,000 U.S. Dollars)
  74. 5.6 Characteristics of Employed and Private Practice U.S. Physicians in 2016
  75. 5.7 Employment in Private Healthcare Industries as a Percentage of Total Private Employment, 1990–2015 Annual Averages
  76. 6.1 Example of the Application of Out-of-Pocket Expenses to Payment of Healthcare Charges
  77. 6.2 Example of the Application of Out-of-Pocket Expenses to Payment for Pharmaceuticals
  78. 6.3 Percentage of People by Type of Health Insurance Coverage—2016
  79. 6.4 Evolution of Blue Cross and Blue Shield Logos
  80. 6.5 Largest Tax Expenditures in 2017
  81. 6.6 ERISA
  82. 6.7 Percentage of Covered Workers in Partially or Completely Self-Funded Plans, by Firm Size, 2017
  83. 6.8 COBRA and HIPAA (Insurance Provisions)
  84. 6.9 Personal Healthcare Spending Accounts
  85. 6.10 Medical Savings Accounts—Experience in South Africa
  86. 6.11 For Firms Offering Health Benefits, Percentage that Offer an HDHP/HRA and/or an HSA-Qualified HDHP, 2005–2017
  87. 6.12 VEBA Example
  88. 6.13 VEBA Regulation
  89. 6.14 State Health Insurance Marketplace Types, 2018
  90. 6.15 Average Annual Premiums for Single and Family Coverage, 2014–2017
  91. 6.16 Average Individual Market Medical Loss Ratios, 2011–2017
  92. 6.17 Plan Selections During the 2014–2018 Open Enrollment Periods
  93. 6.18 Demographic and Plan Characteristics of Consumers, 2018
  94. 6.19 Organizational Chart for Medicare: Policy and Financial Flows
  95. 6.20 Medicare Administrative Contractors for Parts A and B (October 2017)
  96. 6.21 Medigap Policy Descriptions
  97. 6.22 Medicare Benefit Payments by Type of Service, 2016
  98. 6.23 Example of APC Methodology
  99. 6.24 Prospective Payment Systems for Medicare Part A
  100. 6.25 Sample Effects of PPS Changes on Cost and Utilization of Healthcare Services
  101. 6.26 Medicare Premiums for 2019
  102. 6.27 Growth in the Volume of Clinician Services per Fee-for-Service Beneficiary, 2000–2016
  103. 6.28 Summary of Features of the Resource Based Relative Value Scale
  104. 6.29 Brief History of Medicare's Volume and Spending Target Payment Methods
  105. 6.30 Sample of CMS Hierarchical Condition Categories
  106. 6.31 PACE Organizations
  107. 6.32 Different Requirements and Provisions Apply to Different Types of MA Plans
  108. 6.33 Enrollment in Medicare Advantage Plans
  109. 6.34 Enrollment in Medicare Advantage Plans, Distribution by Plan Type, 2017
  110. 6.35 Standard Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit, 2018
  111. 6.36 Medicare Part D Costs 2019
  112. 6.37 Hemodialysis and Arteriovenous Graft
  113. 6.38 Peritoneal Dialysis
  114. 6.39 Key Features of the ESRD Prospective Payment Program
  115. 6.40 Use of Dialysis Drugs Before and After Prospective Payment System Implementation in 2011
  116. 6.41 Total spending per year by modality for ESRD beneficiaries
  117. 6.42 Total Medicare ESRD Expenditures, by Modality, 2004–2015
  118. 6.43 Annual Percentage Change in Medicare ESRD Spending, 2004–2016
  119. 6.44 Sources of Medicare Revenue, 2016
  120. 6.45 Medicare Benefit Payments by Type of Service, 2016
  121. 6.46 State Medicaid Expansion Decisions as of May 2018
  122. 6.47 Mandatory Categorically Needy Examples
  123. 6.48 Percentage of Populations Covered by Medicaid
  124. 6.49 Medicaid Mandatory and Optional Benefits
  125. 6.50 Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP), Fiscal Year 2019
  126. 6.51 Distribution of Medicaid Benefit Spending by Eligibility Group and Service Category
  127. 6.52 Estimated Medicaid Enrollment and Expenditures by Enrollment Group, as Share of Total, Fiscal Year 2016
  128. 6.53 Annual Percentage Changes in Total Medicaid Enrollment and Spending Changes, Fiscal Years 1998–2018
  129. 6.54 Medicaid Risk-Based Managed Care Enrollment by State
  130. 6.55 Veterans Integrated Service Networks
  131. 6.56 VA Provided Care Under the Medical Benefits Package
  132. 6.57 Veterans Population Projections 2017–2037
  133. 6.58 Trends in the Number of Eligible TRICARE Beneficiaries by Beneficiary Group, Fiscal Years 2015–2017
  134. 6.59 TRICARE Beneficiary Plan Choice by Age Group
  135. 6.60 TRICARE Retiree Coverage Costs with the National Average Employer-Provided Family Coverage
  136. 6.61 Pioneering Concepts in Public Law 86–382, Passed on September 28, 1959
  137. 6.62 Performance Areas and Domains of the FEHB Plan Performance Assessment
  138. 6.63 Distribution of Health Plan Enrollment for Covered Workers, by Plan Type, 1988–2017
  139. 6.64 Definitions of Managed Care
  140. 6.65 Patient-Centered Medical Home
  141. 6.66 Physicians' Control of Healthcare Expenses
  142. 6.67 Distributing Prepaid Premiums
  143. 6.68 Reasons for HMO Cost Savings
  144. 6.69 Strategies to Lower Pharmaceutical Costs
  145. 6.70 Pharmacy Benefit Management Market Share, by Total Equivalent Prescription Claims Managed, 2017
  146. 6.71 Definition of Disease Management
  147. 6.72 Different Methods Managed Care Plans Use to Compensate Physicians
  148. 6.73 Percentage of Covered Workers in a Plan that Includes a General Annual Deductible for Single Coverage, by Plan Type, 2006–2017
  149. 6.74 Among Covered Workers with a Copayment for a Primary Care Physician Office Visit, Distribution of Copayments, 2006–2018
  150. 6.75 Among Firms Offering Health Benefits, Percentage of Firms Whose Largest Plan Has Various Features, by Firm Size, 2017
  151. 7.1 Frameworks for Studying Healthcare Technology
  152. 7.2 10 High-Level Classes for Studying Patient Safety
  153. 7.3 Conceptual Framework for the International Classification for Patient Safety
  154. 7.4 Explanation of the 510(k) Process
  155. 7.5 What Does FDA Regulate?
  156. 7.6 FDA Global Strategic Framework for SSFFC Medical Products
  157. 7.7 2019 Top 10 Patient Safety Concerns
  158. 7.8 Stages in the Typical Brand-Name Drug Development Process
  159. 7.9 Drug Discovery and Development
  160. 7.10 Pharma Industry Merger and Acquisition Analysis, 1995 to 2015
  161. 7.11 Flow of Goods and Financial Transactions among Players in the U.S. Commercial Pharmaceutical Supply Chain
  162. 7.12 Express Scripts Prescription Price Index
  163. 7.13 Reference/Index Pricing Methods and Example Countries
  164. 7.14 Cost of Sequencing One Genome
  165. 7.15 Patient Confidence with Physician Evaluation
  166. 7.16 Other Technologies Found to Be Ineffective or Harmful for Some or All Indications
  167. 8.1 Three Categories of Health IT Functionality
  168. 8.2 SNOMED and LOINC Coding
  169. 8.3 Specialist Lexicon and Lexical Tools
  170. 8.4 Semantic Network
  171. 8.5 Metathesaurus
  172. 8.6 Format of the TEFCA
  173. 8.7 Organization of the TEFCA
  174. 8.8 Draft USCDI Version 1 Data Classes
  175. 8.9 Evaluation of the State HIE Cooperative Agreement Program
  176. 8.10 Evaluation of the Beacon Community Cooperative Agreement Program
  177. 8.11 Sample Scheme for e-Prescribing HIE
  178. 8.12 Structure of the ONC Health IT Certification Program
  179. 8.13 Organizational Barriers to HIT Implementation
  180. 8.14 Blockchain Use in a Healthcare System
  181. 8.15 Examples of “as a Service” Offerings Marketed as Cloud-Based Products
  182. 8.16 Top Five Healthcare IT Companies (by Installations) as of July 2017
  183. 9.1 American Consumer Satisfaction Index 2017 (Scores Out of 100)
  184. 9.2 Causes of “Lack of Perfection” in Surgical Treatment
  185. 9.3 Original ACS 1919 Standards
  186. 9.4 Recommendation Grade Explanations
  187. 9.5 Initial 10 Quality Measures of the HQA
  188. 9.6 Sample National Patient Safety Goals
  189. 9.7 Aims and Priorities of the NQS
  190. 9.8 Relationship of Aims, Priorities, and Levers
  191. 9.9 National Quality Strategy Priorities and Goals, with Illustrative Measures
  192. 9.10 Quality Improvement Council Affinity Groups
  193. 9.11 National Prevention Strategy Goal, Strategic Directions, and Priorities
  194. 9.12 Complexity of Quality-Related Activities Confronting Hospitals
  195. 9.13 Evolution of the Healthy People Program
  196. 9.14 Dimensions in Definitions of Quality
  197. 9.15 Examples of International Quality Improvement Organizations
  198. 9.16 How People Make Decisions About Hospital Choice
  199. 9.17 Transformation from Quality Assurance to Quality Improvement

FOREWORD

I have been teaching a survey course on the American healthcare system in MBA and MPH programs for more than 30 years. During this time, students have constantly expressed frustration at the system's incredible complexity, leading to inefficiencies and wastefulness. In fact, calling it a system is really a misnomer—it is more like a cluster of variably interrelated subsystems. One needs only to look at the financing systems for proof of this fragmentation: Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), employer-based health insurance, Health Insurance Exchange–based coverage, Veterans Administration care, and TRICARE for families of active military. These mechanisms are just the major ways healthcare is paid in our country. Add to this disarray the complexities of different types of provider organizations, technology companies, and other healthcare entities and a person is likely to offer one of three solutions to our problems: throw up one's hands and walk away, offer incremental changes, or blow up the system and start over by, for example, instituting a single payer system.

In order to make sense of the complexity of these problems and solutions, this textbook takes a very different approach from others textbooks on this subject. For each topic, I present a detailed, relevant history as background for understanding its current status. I take this approach for two reasons. First, before we can make plans for improvements, we need to fully understand where we are now. To understand where we are now, we must understand how we got here. Second, with the exception of innovative technologies, nothing in healthcare is new. For example, Western society has tried many types of financing, organizational structures, and regulations. Each of these attempts has created its own set of problems. Since the problems are also not new, it is necessary to understand what was tried in the past to fix them, the contexts in which the solutions were attempted, and why these attempts succeeded or failed.

With this approach, it also becomes easier to deliver three overarching goals for this book.

First, provide frameworks for understanding problems. When one is faced with a difficulty in the healthcare system, it is useful to understand the type of problem it is. For examples: Is it a quality issue? Is it an issue of a trade-off between quality and access? Is it a pricing issue? Once the problem is properly framed, it can be placed in the context of the entire system, and rational solutions can begin to form. Consider a medical analogy. A patient presents with symptoms. If a physician can identify them as belonging to problems in a particular organ system, investigation is then much easier and can lead to a more rapid diagnosis and treatment plan.

Second, provide facts. A working knowledge of the subject is always necessary to begin framing a problem. For example, understanding the structure and funding streams of Medicare is essential to identifying key issues and solutions.

Third, healthcare is changing so rapidly that it is difficult to keep up with regulations, organizational changes, and technological innovations, to name a few. I have, therefore, provided extensive resources so that one can get updates more easily. This last item would seem easy in the internet age. However, in writing this book, I have been struck by the fragmentation of information and, occasionally, the errors in what has been accepted as “common knowledge.” For example, I found it interesting that HIPAA issues (the federal program that deals with patient privacy and security) are handled by the Office of Civil Rights.

As you read this book, I hope you will gain an appreciation not only of the complexities and problems of our healthcare system but also of the opportunities to implement truly effective and meaningful changes.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

While this work is a single-author text, the professional career encouragement and support I have received have been invaluable to its conceptualization and execution. Unfortunately, the three mentors I wish to thank are no longer with us: Professor Morton Kamien, Dean Emeritus Donald Jacobs, and my father, Mervin Shalowitz, MD, to whom this book is dedicated.

The personal encouragement and patience of my wife, Madeleine Shalowitz, MD, MBA, has been priceless. My children also deserve a note of appreciation for their gentle nudges: “So how's the book going, Dad?” Thanks to David Shalowitz, MD, MS, Kira Spivack, and Ilana Shalowitz. Finally, a special acknowledgment to the late Murphy Shalowitz, who was my constant companion throughout the writing of this book.