Cover Page

Business Sustainability in Asia

Compliance, Performance, and Integrated Reporting and Assurance

 

 

ZABIHOLLAH REZAEE

JUDY TSUI

PETER CHENG

GAOGUANG ZHOU

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wiley Logo

To my parents Fazlollah and Fatemeh, sister Monireh, wife Soheila, and children Nick and Rose – ZR

To my husband Andrew, my son Timothy, daughter-in-law Catherine and my granddaughter Chloe, my daughter Jaclyn and son-in-law Daniel, my son Benjamin and daughter-in-law Jessica – JT

To Alex and my children Nicholas, Cecilia, and Stephanie – PC

To my parents – GZ

Foreword

BY DR KELVIN WONG

The book entitled Business Sustainability in Asia, coauthored by Professors Rezaee, Tsui, Cheng, and Zhou, is an excellent reference for the emergence of business sustainability worldwide and particularly in Asia. Business sustainability has gained significant attention from global investors, regulators, the business community, public companies, and academicians in the past decade. This book focuses on five dimensions of sustainability performance:economic, governance, social, ethical, and environmental (EGSEE). It addresses the increasing focus on business sustainability and its factors of performance, disclosure, and risk and their implications for business practice, education, and research worldwide. Proper measurement of sustainability performance, as well as accurate and reliable disclosure of sustainability performance, and effective assessment of sustainability risks remain major challenges for organizations of different types and sizes, particularly in Asia. The book focuses on business sustainability in 12 jurisdictions in Asia from the Mainland China to Hong Kong, among others,and Vietnam. The sustainability theme in Asia is important for many reasons including the significant growth in sustainability efforts and activities in Asia in the past decades. Moreover, Asia has stepped up in forging an alliance with Europe to take a leading role on environmental initiatives by tackling climate change.

Given the continuing growth in business sustainability in Asia, this is a comprehensive book that introduces the emergence of business sustainability, followed by in-depth discussions of the three important business sustainability factors of performance, disclosure, and risk. The book offers guidance to organizations worldwide to properly integrate all five EGSEE dimensions of sustainability into their business models, strategic plans, and practices. It also provides guidelines for complete and accurate measurement, recognition, and disclosure of all five EGSEE dimensions of sustainability performance in an integrated reporting model.I highly recommend this book as a valuable resource in advancing business sustainability worldwide and, particularly in Asia. I believe anyone who is involved with business sustainability from the corporate board of directors to executives, investors, policymakers, regulators, and standard-setters should buy and read this book.

Dr. Kelvin Wong
Executive Director and Deputy Managing Director of COSCO SHIPPING Ports Limited
Chairman of the Financial Reporting Council, Hong Kong
Immediate Past Chairman of the Hong Kong Institute of Directors

Preface

Business sustainability has advanced from branding and greenwashing to strategic imperative and impact investing in sustainable finance in the past decade. It is defined in this book as a process of focusing on the achievement of all five dimensions of sustainability performance namely economic, governance, social, ethical and environmental (EGSEE) in creating shared value for all stakeholders. Integrated reporting on both financial elements of economic sustainability performance (ESP) and non-financial elements encompassing governance, social, ethical, and environmental (GSEE) dimensions of sustainability performance has been demanded by investors, required and/or encouraged by regulators and performed by business organizations worldwide. Global business organizations report their integrated financial ESP and non-financial (GSEE) sustainability performance in creating shared value for all stakeholders from shareholders to customers, employees, suppliers, creditors, environmental agencies and organizations, government and society.

This book specifically focuses on business sustainability in Asia, for several reasons. First, sustainability activities in Asia have significantly grown in the past decade as business organizations in the region have faced greater pressure from regulators to engage in sustainability and corporate social responsibility (CSR) programs. Second, this trend is expected to continue as Asian countries in general and Mainland China in particular step up alliances with European countries to take a leading role in CSR and environmental initiatives through addressing product quality and safety, and tackling climate change. Third, the recent decision of the United States to exit the 2015 Paris Agreement is expected to encourage other countries (e.g., Mainland China, India, Singapore) to accelerate the pace by providing leadership in sustainability initiatives. Finally, the achievement of sustainable economic growth, prosperity and performance has been observed in Asia and is expected to continue in the foreseeable future.

A number of professional organizations, including the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), the International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC), the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), and the Corporate Reporting Dialogue (CRD), have issued numerous sustainability reporting and assurance guidelines to assist business organizations in disclosing their economic and GSEE sustainability performance to all stakeholders. Sustainability performance information can be disclosed on a voluntary basis or on a mandatory basis. In Hong Kong, there are listing standards that require listed companies to comply with ESG requirements in annual reports commencing in the 2016 fiscal year. Large European companies (more than 6,000 employees) are now required to disclose their environmental, social and diversity activities for the 2017 financial year and onwards. The Delaware Certification of Adoption of Transparency and Sustainability Standards Act was signed into law on June 27, 2018; this represents Delaware's initiative to support sustainability practices by enabling Delaware-governed entities to disclose their commitment to CSR and sustainability.

Global business organizations have issued integrated sustainability reports on all or some of the five EGSEE dimensions of sustainability performance in the past decade. Theoretically, companies that effectively manage their business sustainability by improving EGSEE performance conduct their business more effectively and ethically, enhance their reputation, fulfill their social responsibility and environmental commitments, and thus contribute to their bottom-line financial economic sustainability performance. However, ESP and GSEE sustainability performance disclosures supplement each other and are not mutually exclusive. The relative importance of EGSEE sustainability performance with respect to each other and their integrated contribution to the overall firm value maximization is affected by whether EGSEE are viewed as complementary or conflicting factors in the context of sustainability theories. Sustainability performance dimensions (EGSEE) can be seen as complementary because firms must be financially sustainable in the long term to be able to perform well in the other areas of governance, social, ethical and environmental activities. This book offers guidance to organizations for proper measurement, recognition and reporting of all five EGSEE dimensions of sustainability performance. Sustainability integrated reporting refers to the continuous process of promoting, measuring, recognizing, reporting and auditing sustainability performance in the five areas of EGSEE. Traditionally, organizations have reported their financial performance on economic transactions. Given the growing global attention to corporate sustainability and the major economies in developing nations, this book examines the emergence of corporate sustainability in Asia, particularly in Hong Kong and Mainland China.

In this book, five primary themes will present a framework for the five dimensions (EGSEE) of business sustainability performance. First, business sustainability is driven by and built on the stakeholder theory, which is the theoretical basis for creating shared value for all stakeholders. Second, the main goal and objective for business organizations is to maximize firm value by improving financial and non-financial dimensions (EGSEE) of sustainability performance. The third theme focuses on the time horizon of balancing short-, medium-, and long-term performance, with a keen emphasis on long-term sustainable performance. The fourth theme is the multi-dimensional nature of sustainability performance in all EGSEE areas, which are interrelated. The final theme of the book is its focus on and relevance to Asia because sustainability initiatives and activities in Asia have significantly grown in the past decade and are expected to continue to grow in the future. The relative importance of the dimensions with respect to each other and their contribution to the firm's overall long-term value maximization is affected by whether these EGSEE dimensions are viewed as competing, conflicting or complementing.

We hope you will find this book a valuable resource in understanding and promoting business sustainability worldwide and particularly in Asia. This book will be of interest to anyone who is involved with business sustainability, CSR and corporate governance, the financial reporting process, investment decisions, legal and financial advising, audit functions and business sustainability education. Specifically, corporations, business executives, board members, internal and external auditors, accountants, lawmakers, regulators, standard-setters, users of financial statements (investors, creditors, and pensioners), investor activists, business academics and other professionals (attorneys, financial analysts and bankers) will benefit from this book. Business sustainability performance dimensions, principles, mechanisms and functions as well as sustainability compliance, integrated reporting and assurance presented in this book are applicable to organizations of all types and sizes. Profit-oriented enterprises, non-governmental organizations, state-owned enterprises and not-for-profit and governmental entities can benefit from our discussions. We hope you will find this book useful and valuable in achieving your personal and professional goals.

Zabihollah Rezaee
Judy Tsui
Peter Cheng
Gaoguang Zhou
3/06/2019

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the quality reporting that is cited throughout the book including publications of professional organizations such as the Global Reporting Initiative, the International Integrated Reporting Council, and the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board.

The encouragement and support of our colleagues at the University of Memphis and Hong Kong Baptist University are also acknowledged. The assistance of our graduate students Charles Bell, Matthew Cantin, Chinenye Egbuna, Yueming Li, Kai Wang, and Xuemei Zheng is also appreciated. We thank the members of the John Wiley & Sons, Inc., team for their hard work and dedication, including Koushika Ramesh for managing the book through the production process, Jean-Karl Martin for their marketing efforts and Sheck Cho, Executive Editor for editorial guidance.

Our special thanks are due to our families: the Rezaee family, the Rezaee family, the Tsui family, the Cheng family, and the Zhou family Without their love, enthusiasm, and support, this book would not have come to fruition when it did.

Zabihollah Rezaee
Judy Tsui
Peter Cheng
Gaoguang Zhou
March 06, 2019

List of Abbreviations

Accounting Standards Council ASC
Accounting Standards for Business Enterprises ASBE
American Accounting Association AAA
American Certified Fraud Examiners ACFE
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants AICPA
Asian Corporate Governance Association ACGA
Association of Advanced Collegiate School of Business AACSB
Association of Chartered Certified Accountants ACCA
Board of Directors BOD
Carbon Reduction Commitment CRC
Certified Public Accountants CPAs
Certified Sustainability Reporting Assurer CSRA
Chartered Global Management Accountants CGMA
Chartered Institute of Management Accountants CIMA
Chief Sustainability Officer CSO
Chinese Communist Party CCP
Climate Disclosure Standards Board CDSB
Coalition for Environmentally Responsible Economies CERES
Corporate Disclosure and Governance Committee CCDG
Corporate Governance Committee CGC
Corporate Governance Report CGR
Corporate Social Responsibility CSR
Department of Environment and Natural Resources DENR
Economic Sustainability Performance ESP
Economic, Social and Governance ESG
Economic, Governance, Social, Ethical and Environmental EGSEE
Environmental Management Systems EMS
Environmental Protection Agency EPA
Environmental Protection Bureau EPB
Earnings Per Share EPS
Extensible Business Reporting Language XBRL
Financial Reporting Standards Council FRSC
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act FCPA
Foreign Direct Investment FDI
General Agreement on Trade in Services GATS
Global Impact Investing Network GIIN
Governance, Social, Ethical and Environmental GSEE
Greenhouse Gas GHG
Gross Domestic Product GDP
Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants HKICPA
Hong Kong Stock Exchange HKSE
Impact Investment Exchange IIX
Information Technology IT
Initial Public Offerings IPOs
Institute of Internal Auditors IIA
Institute of Management Accountants IMA
Internal Control Over Financial Reporting ICFR
International Accounting Standards Committee IASC
International Accounting Standards IAS
International Auditing & Assurance Standards Board IAASB
International Corporate Governance Network ICGN
International Federation of Accountants IFAC
International Financial Reporting Standards IFRS
International Integrated Reporting Council IIRC
International Monetary Fund IMF
International Organization of Securities Commissions IOSCO
International Standardization Organization ISO
International Standards on Assurance Engagements ISAE
Investor Responsibility Research Center Institute IRRCI
Key Performance Indicators KPIs
Lead Director Network LDN
Management Discussion and Analysis MD&A
Multi-national Companies MNCs
Multiple Bottom Line MBL
National Bureau of Statistics NBS
National Committee on Corporate Governance NCCG
National Greening Program NGP
National Human Rights Institution NHRI
National Stock Exchange NSE
Net Present Value NPV
Non-Governmental Organizations NGOs
Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development OECD
People's Republic of China PRC
Principles for Responsible Investment PRI
Public Company Accounting Oversight Board PCAOB
Return on Assets ROA
Return on Equity ROE
Sarbanes-Oxley SOX
Securities and Exchange Commission SEC
Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises SMEs
Social Investment Forum SIF
Socially Responsible Investment SRI
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards SFAS
Superfund Amendment and Reauthorization Act SARA
Sustainability Accounting Standards Board SASB
Sustainable Development Goals SDGs
Sustainable Management and Investment Guideline SMILE
Sustainable Supply Chain Management SSCM
Tokyo Stock Exchange TSE
Toronto Stock Exchange TSX
Triple Bottom Line TBL
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development UNCTAD
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization UNESCO
United Nations Environment Programme UNEP
United Nations Global Compact UNGC
United Nations Sustainability Development Goals UNSDGs
United Nations UN
World Business Council for Sustainable Development WBCSD
World Economic Forum WEF
World Federation of Exchanges WFE
World Trade Organization WTO