Cover Page

Beyond One Health

From Recognition to Results


Edited by John A. Herrmann and Yvette J. Johnson‐Walker


University of Illinois, IL, USA










logo.gif

 

 

For Wanda, who always knew the way; and for Anne and Kate, who are my guideposts.

J.A. Herrmann

For Mom, Lauren, and Lamar – my shelter from the storm; and for Ikenna, Ndidi, and Amaya – my windows of hope.

Y.J. Johnson‐Walker

List of Contributors

Jonathan D. Alpern, MD
Infectious Disease Fellow
Department of Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases & International Medicine
School of Medicine
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Casey Barton Behravesh, MS, DVM, DrPH, DACVPM
Captain, US Public Health Service
Director, One Health Office
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Atlanta, Georgia, USA

Val R. Beasley, DVM, PhD, Diplomate ABVT
Professor of Veterinary, Wildlife, and Ecological Toxicology
Department of Veterinary and Biomedical Sciences
College of Agricultural Sciences
The Pennsylvania State University
University Park, Pennsylvania, USA

Matteo Convertino, PhD, PE
Assistant Professor
Division of Environmental Health Sciences & PH Informatics
School of Public Health
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Meggan Craft, PhD
Assistant Professor of Disease Ecology
Department of Veterinary Population Medicine
College of Veterinary Medicine
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

William J. Craven, JD
Chief Consultant
California State Senate
Sacramento, California, USA

Timur Durrani, MD, MPH, MBA
Co‐Director of the Western States Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit
Assistant Clinical Professor
University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine
San Francisco, California, USA

Robert V. Ellis, MD, FAAFP
Associate Professor
University of Cincinnati College of Medicine
Cincinnati, Ohio, USA

Thomas R. Gillespie, PhD
Associate Professor
Departments of Environmental Sciences & Environmental Health
Emory University & Rollins School of Public Health
Math and Science Center
Georgia, USA

Marja‐Liisa Hänninen, DVM
Professor Emeritus
Department of Food Hygiene and Environmental Health
University of Helsinki
Helsinki, Finland

John A. Herrmann, DVM, MPH, DACT
Clinical Associate Professor
Director, DVM/MPH Joint Degree Program
Center for One Health Illinois
College of Veterinary Medicine
University of Illinois at Urbana‐Champaign
Urbana, Illinois, USA;
Division Affiliate
Epidemiology and Biostatistics
School of Public Health
University of Illinois at Chicago
Chicago, Illinois, USA

Ronald C. Hershow, MD
Director, Division of Epidemiology and Biostatistics
School of Public Health
University of Illinois at Chicago
Chicago, Illinois, USA

Ari Hörman, DVM, PhD, MPH
Department of Food Hygiene and Environmental Health
University of Helsinki
Helsinki, Finland

Daniel Hryhorczuk, MD, MPH, FACMT
Clinical Professor of Medical Toxicology
Director, Environmental Health, Center for Global Health
College of Medicine
University of Illinois at Chicago
Chicago, Illinois, USA;
Professor Emeritus
Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences and Epidemiology
School of Public Health
University of Illinois at Chicago
Chicago, Illinois, USA

William D. Hueston, DVM, PhD, Diplomate ACVPM, Epidemiology Specialty
Professor Emeritus
College of Veterinary Medicine and School of Public Health
Global Leadership Programs
Center for Animal Health and Food Safety
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Yvette J. Johnson‐Walker DVM, MS, PhD
Clinical Epidemiologist
Center for One Health Illinois
University of Illinois Urbana‐Champaign
College of Veterinary Medicine
Urbana, Illinois, USA

Laura H. Kahn, MD, MPH, MPP
Research Scholar
Program on Science and Global Security
Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs Princeton University
Princeton, New Jersey, USA;
Co‐Founder, One Health Initiative

John B. Kaneene DVM, MPH, PhD, FAES, FAVES
University Distinguished Professor of Epidemiology and Public Health
Director, Center for Comparative Epidemiology
Michigan State University
East Lansing, Michigan, USA

Shaun Kennedy, PhD
President and CEO
Food Systems Institute
St Paul, Minnesota;
Adjunct Associate Professor
College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Sandra L. Lefebvre, BA, BSc (Hons Neuroscience), DVM, PhD
Assistant Editor, JAVMA and AJVR
American Veterinary Medical Association
Schaumburg, Illinois, USA

Jeffrey M. Levengood, PhD
Illinois Natural History Survey, Prairie Research Institute
University of Illinois at Urbana‐Champaign
Urbana, Illinois, USA

Thomas P. Meehan, DVM
Vice‐President of Veterinary Services
Chicago Zoological Society
Adjunct Clinical Assistant Professor
Veterinary Clinical Medicine
College of Veterinary Medicine
Brookfield Zoo
University of Illinois at Urbana‐Champaign
Brookfield, Illinois, USA

Yvonne Nadler, DVM, MPH
Program Manager
Zoo and Aquarium All Hazards Preparedness, Response, and Recovery Fusion Center
Silver Spring, Maryland, USA

Megin Nichols, DVM, MPH, DACVPM
Lead, Enteric Zoonoses Activity
Division of Foodborne, Waterborne, and Environmental Diseases
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases (NCEZID)
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Atlanta, Georgia, USA

Kenneth E. Nusbaum, DVM, PhD
Professor Emeritus
College of Veterinary Medicine
Auburn University
Auburn, Alabama, USA

Kevin O’Brien, PhD
Director
Illinois Sustainable Technology Center Prairie Research Institute
University of Illinois at Urbana‐Champaign
Urbana, Illinois, USA

Robert H. Poppenga, DVM, PhD, DABVT
Professor
CAHFS Toxicology Laboratory
School of Veterinary Medicine
University of California
West Health Sciences Drive
Davis, California, USA

Cheryl Robertson, PhD, MPH, RN, FAAN
Associate Professor
Chair, Population Health and Systems Cooperative Unit
School of Nursing
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Innocent B. Rwego, BVM, MSc, PhD
Assistant Professor
Department of Veterinary Population Medicine
College of Veterinary Medicine
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA;
Senior Technical Lead for Africa
USAID One Health Workforce Project
University of Minnesota‐Makerere University Uganda Hub
Kampala, Uganda

Christopher A. Shaffer, PhD
Assistant Professor
Department of Anthropology
Grand Valley State University
Allendale, Michigan, USA

William Stauffer, MD, MSPH, FASTMH
Professor
Department of Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases & International Medicine
Department of Pediatrics, Infectious Diseases
School of Medicine and Public Health
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Lauren Stevenson, MHS
Assessment Epidemiologist
Division of Foodborne, Waterborne, and Environmental Diseases
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Atlanta, Georgia, USA

Robert V. Tauxe, MD, MPH
Director
Division of Foodborne, Waterborne, and Environmental Diseases
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Atlanta, Georgia, USA

Dominic A. Travis, DVM, MS
Associate Professor
Division of Ecosystem Health
Department of Veterinary Population Medicine
College of Veterinary Medicine
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Ed G.M. van Klink, DVM, PhD, Dipl. ECVPH, MRCVS
Senior Lecturer in Veterinary Public Health
School of Veterinary Science
University of Bristol
Lower Langford
Bristol, United Kingdom;
Wageningen Bioveterinary Research
Lelystad, The Netherlands

Donald J. Wuebbles, PhD
Harry E. Preble Endowed Professor of Atmospheric Sciences
Department of Atmospheric Sciences
University of Illinois
Urbana, Illinois, USA

Foreword

We encourage you to set aside time to read Beyond One Health: From Recognition to Results. We hope that you will be as inspired by its contents as we are.

One Health is one of the great innovations of our time. It is an idea, a concept, a way of thinking and working, and a means to organize action. One Health starts from a recognition that 75% of the new infections affecting humans come from animals. The risks of animal diseases can be decreased through proper attention to livestock health in livestock production: the One Health approach guides efforts to intensify production. It recognizes the benefits of food systems that are sensitive to nutrition and the threats posed by infections that are resistant to antimicrobial therapies.

The One Health idea came to life in 2004 as scientists considered how best to tackle diseases that move between human, domestic animal, and wildlife populations. It reflected experiences with the Ebola virus disease, avian influenza, and chronic wasting disease. It is set out as the Manhattan principles (https://www.cdc.gov/onehealth/pdfs/manhattan/twelve_manhattan_principles.pdf) for One World, One Health.1 It is an international, interdisciplinary approach for tackling threats to the health of life on Earth. It has practical application for reducing risks of unsafe foods and diseases that move from animals to humans.

One Health connects science and systems to the needs of society. It has matured into a new way of thinking and working and contributes to the health of both humans and animals. It links several disciplines that focus on health. It helps professionals to see their work differently and to do it with new purpose. It stimulates integration when remaining separate is less effective. One Health frames how we speak and act: it encourages us to focus on the interfaces between human, animal, and environmental systems. It helps us make sense of multiple interacting determinants of illness. It helps us to better reduce risk and prepare for threats.

Many of us with coordination responsibilities have found that One Health makes our joint working more effective and efficient. It makes sense on the farm, in the factory, and at home, encouraging us to prevent costly outbreaks.

More recently, One Health has helped with restructuring institutions and transforming education. It helped drive collaboration between the World Health Organization (WHO), the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE), and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). It stimulated new academic departments and degree programmes. It provided a basis for local and national governments to combine animal, human, and environmental health programs, and to reap economic benefits.

Beyond One Health: from Recognition to Results offers us an update on One Health topics from the perspectives of different professional and academic disciplines. It includes an analysis of different threats to people and planet (including zoonoses and climate change), the epidemiology that underlies One Health, as well as the evidence base for different One Health policies and their benefits. It shows how One Health is best approached from a systems perspective and explains the importance of good leadership in making One Health a reality.

If we want to learn how One Health can best be applied in practice, we should study its use in different situations. In this book, we can see how One Health approaches help when analyzing risk and devising prevention, preparedness, and response strategies; when monitoring the evolution of threats and establishing early warning systems; or when prioritizing actions and coordinating actors during implementation. We can understand how One Health has been used in responses to avian influenza, yellow fever, Zika, Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS), and Ebola.

When combining animal and environmental health practice, we must be sensitive to variations in motivations, responsibilities, and accountability of practitioners in these disciplines. In our experience, the One Health approach is especially useful when coalitions of actors are being established and a consensus is being built. It should be applied in ways that are sensitive to context, adapted to capabilities of systems (for public, veterinary, and environmental health), and adjusted to ecosystem, economic, and societal realities of interfaces between humans, animals, and nature.

We are starting to see One Health approaches being used to frame analyses of costs, benefits, acceptability, and scalability of different interventions. Academic groups are often asked to provide the evidence base for One Health policies and interventions. Their inputs are most helpful when interdisciplinary research methods are used. This is especially necessary when exploring links among environmental dynamics, disease vectors, pathogens, and human susceptibility.

Enlightened approaches like One Health – which focus on prevention and response from the perspectives of multiple disciplines – are vital to success in achieving the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and in building a common future for all. This book will help you move along that path.

Chadia Wannous
David Nabarro

Chadia Wannous, PhD, is a Public Health professional and expert in prevention, emergency preparedness, and risk reduction for health threats. She previously served in several senior policy advisory positions with the UN.

David Nabarro, MD, is a medical doctor and Adviser on Sustainable Development. He previously served as Special Adviser to the United Nations Secretary‐General.

Note

Foreword

The naturalist and conservationist, John Muir, once stated, “When one tugs at a single thing in nature, he finds that it is attached to the rest of the world.” The interconnectedness that Muir described in the early twentieth century is much more profound today, and much more consequential, regarding our health. The globalization of trade, travel, information, and investments, integrated and consolidated global food systems, urbanization, and a group of anthropogenic drivers that negatively impact our ecosystems, have created a new dynamic and an unprecedented interdependence among the health and well‐being of people, animals, and our environment. The complex construct that describes these three domains of health is termed “One Health” and, indeed, tugging on any one of these domains demonstrates their significant attachments to one another. As a corollary to this axiom, we can no longer focus on health through a single lens or discipline.

Our new twenty‐first century interdependence, including social, economic, political, and biological factors, has created new threats and risks to our health and has produced ecological changes that have fractured our planet. Several decades ago, the concept of One Health re‐emerged from past medical thinking and gained important traction and acceptance. Recently, there have been many articles and books published focusing on One Health but, fortunately and very timely, this book has added special insights and brought together diverse disciplines and thinking to give us a better understanding of One Health in our contemporary lives, with an important and unique emphasis on operationalizing the concept. The book’s authors have substantially improved our understanding of the key themes of One Health, added to our knowledge base, and stressed that new skills and competencies need to be acquired to successfully address the threats to human, animal, and ecosystem health.

The factors and drivers of our interdependent world, and increasingly risky lives, show no signs of abating; rather, they are accelerating. These drivers are leading to the intensification of the human‐animal‐ecosystem interface and causing further ecological damage. One consequence of this reality has been the dramatic increase in zoonotic diseases worldwide over the last few decades, which is thoroughly detailed in several chapters. This book also discusses the serious consequences of the degradation of our water resources and ecosystems, as well as threats to biodiversity and food security, all underpinned by climate change. The authors present evidence that our complex and interconnected world has generated a group of “wicked problems” that demand our attention and resources to resolve. A key feature of “wicked problems” is the recognition that past solutions and practices are not likely to be relevant or effective when applied to today’s unparalleled challenges. A One Health mindset and an ability to work holistically across disciplines need to become the new norm to address complex problems and to take appropriate actions. In addition, we must champion new partnerships and innovations, and learn to effectively lead and manage change.

However, our medical fields continue to become progressively more specialized and, at the same time, progressively more isolated and siloed. While we appreciate the impressive advances in medicine, our health systems are increasingly disease‐oriented and reactive. One Health, on the other hand, stresses disease prevention, shifting interventions closer to the origins of the problem, often in our animals and environment. Beyond One Health:From Recognition to Results argues that improving animal and environmental health can be a very effective and cost‐beneficial public health strategy. As this text points out so well, maintaining and improving health must go beyond a strictly disease‐oriented approach to consider the impact of the environment, social‐economic status, genetics and human behavior, and other social determinants of health, which is truly a One Health perspective. This timely book makes the case that we need to normalize good health through this larger and more comprehensive context.

In differentiating Beyond One Health: From Recognition to Results from past One Health books, this book emphasizes the need to translate new knowledge into practice. We know that this transformation is a difficult and dynamic process that involves synthesis, dissemination, exchange, and finally application of One Health knowledge to the maintenance and improvement of health in all of its domains and dimensions. The book’s authors acknowledge and present compelling evidence that critical gaps exist today between the promise of good health and actual results. The book reiterates that developing and implementing new strategies and polices represent the tactics necessary to support a One Health framework and plan of action. In addition, the authors argue in favor of the growing evidence that One Health thinking can offer a favorable value proposition, demonstrating that maintaining the status quo for our current healthcare delivery and disease response system is no longer acceptable, cost‐effective, or scientifically valid.

While we remember John Muir as an outstanding ecological thinker, we also recognize that he was a very effective political spokesperson who understood the importance of translating science and knowledge into policies in support of conservation. Likewise, we need to move One Health from an abstract concept to a catalyst for new policies and interventions that can change the existing dynamic and improve health outcomes across all the domains of health. We understand that there are three stages of translating knowledge into practice, and this book discusses all three throughout its chapters. Awareness, acceptance, and adoption comprise the sectors of translation and all are integrated throughout the text. The authors also stress an important lesson: as we develop and adopt new strategies and policies, we also must design and carry out processes for outcome measurement and evaluation and continuous improvement for them to remain relevant and effective.

We are indebted to the editors and authors who have successfully built momentum toward a more universal acceptance of One Health and, perhaps even more importantly, have been especially instructive in helping us appreciate the need to enact new policies and shift One Health from theory to effective field implementation. They have reminded us, throughout this text, that One Health is likely just to be relegated to an academic exercise if it is not accompanied by a new value proposition, new policies, and more efficient interventions in the rapidly changing human, animal, and environmental health dynamic. Finally, we are grateful for both the intellectual and practical contributions of the book’s editors and authors and are well advised to use their ideas and examples to better address the threats to our health, in all its dimensions.

Lonnie King, DVM, MS, MPA, DACVPM
Professor and Dean Emeritus
College of Veterinary Medicine
Ohio State University

Preface

“One Health” has caught on, some 140 years after Virchow coined the term “zoonoses” and said, “between animal and human medicine there are no dividing lines – nor should there be” (Schultz, 2008). The principles of One Health are often assigned singular ownership of that conceptual triad. However, other models, such as the Ecological Model in public health, eco‐social theory, EcoHealth, conservation medicine, ecological medicine, and others, also take the holistic view that individual or population health outcomes are the result of many interrelated exposures, determinants, and contributing factors, and that an understanding of them, and their relatedness to each other, is required to formulate effective public policy designed to improve health.

Much has been written about One Health, its history and importance, especially in the context of emerging infectious diseases. One cannot minimize previous essays and textbooks focused on the need for viewing modern challenges to population health through a One Health lens, or the many peer reviewed journal articles that framed their research findings as examples of the demand for One Health thinking. We also must appreciate the excellent efforts of various national and international groups devoted to promoting One Health concepts and spreading awareness of their importance. However, we are at an inflection point in world events at which it has never been more critical that policy‐makers set aside their ideologies and prejudices and promote science and technology policies that affect health, broadly defined. Those policies must be based on scientific consensus drawn from independent, well‐constructed, repeatable research that is published for all to read and analyzed in well‐respected, peer reviewed journals. We need to get beyond the abstract and actually do. Centuries ago, the German writer and statesman, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, counseled that knowing and willing to do something is all well and good but eventually we must actually do it.

When we received a request from our publisher to edit a textbook about One Health, we initially declined. There were already four or five excellent books that describe One Health thinking and the challenges associated with it. It was only after we discussed our interest in public policy, and our experiences in the policy formation process, that we came up with the idea to edit a One Health book that is directed at policy solutions. The title of this textbook should be instructive. Our book is intended to serve as a reference for students and professionals in many disciplines, from architecture through urban planning, and not just for those working in traditional healthcare and health‐related fields. The concept of One Health, that human, animal, and ecosystem health are inextricably linked, is an idea that is, at its core, about prevention. One Health may be easy to describe but it is a challenge to operationalize as policy. One Health thinking recognizes the interrelatedness of determinants of health and uses the scientific method to discover how strongly exposures are related to outcomes. Data are tested until they are accepted as fact; those facts can, gradually, after the iterative process of the scientific method, be translated into policy that should be designed to prevent the adverse effects of natural and human‐derived phenomena on an ecosystem and to improve health.

Reference

  1. Schultz, M. (2008). Rudolf Virchow. Emerging Infectious Diseases 14(9), 1480–1481.

John A. Herrmann
Yvette J. Johnson‐Walker