What’s Wrong Series
Paul Harris, What’s Wrong with Climate Politics and How to Fix It
Simon Hix, What’s Wrong with the European Union and How to Fix It
Bill Jordan, What’s Wrong with Social Policy and How to Fix It Thomas G. Weiss, What’s Wrong with the United Nations and How to Fix It, 3rd edition
Rorden Wilkinson, What’s Wrong with the WTO and How to Fix It
polity
Copyright © Bessma Momani, Mark R. Hibben 2018
The right of Bessma Momani, Mark R. Hibben to be identified as Author of this Work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
First published in 2018 by Polity Press
Polity Press
65 Bridge Street
Cambridge CB2 1UR, UK
Polity Press
101 Station Landing, Suite 300
Medford, MA 02155, USA
All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purpose of criticism and review, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher.
ISBN-13: 978-1-5095-0970-6
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
The publisher has used its best endeavours to ensure that the URLs for external websites referred to in this book are correct and active at the time of going to press. However, the publisher has no responsibility for the websites and can make no guarantee that a site will remain live or that the content is or will remain appropriate.
Every effort has been made to trace all copyright holders, but if any have been inadvertently overlooked the publisher will be pleased to include any necessary credits in any subsequent reprint or edition.
For further information on Polity, visit our website: politybooks.com
Debates over the failings of international organizations like the United Nations, the World Trade Organization, and of course the International Monetary Fund (IMF) are among the most pressing issues in global governance. Born out of the spirit of liberal multilateralism following World War II, these institutions and their beliefs are under direct attack by the new politics of reactionary nationalism across Europe and in the United States. In writing this book between 2015 and 2017, we thus find ourselves embedded in a critical historical moment in our analysis of the IMF. In the face of the rising tide of reactionary nationalism, the direction of the IMF’s future actions and degree of effectiveness will strengthen or help unravel the world’s commitment to liberal global governance.
While ultimately champions of the institution, we recognize the multiple areas of controversy tied to the IMF. For many in the developing world, the IMF has been appropriately criticized for its inaction, for its “one size fits all” policies which do not consider local context, and for the imbalance of power among its members, with the most powerful dominating it. The Fund’s current engagement in the troubled Eurozone also highlights the tension born out of deeply held norms that generally champion austerity. The IMF’s past response to the debt crisis of the 1980s and Asian crisis of the late 1990s also highlight pockets of institutional dysfunction that produced devastating effects on the lives of millions of people across the globe. However, the Fund has demonstrated it can learn from its mistakes. Particularly in the time period following the 2008 global financial crisis, the IMF has implemented effective policy reforms and has served as an important voice and advocate for many of the world’s poorest people. This is most salient currently in its commitment to “inclusive growth” and the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals.
This book looks ahead by diagnosing the failures and inconsistencies of the IMF and offering perspectives on the future role of the Fund. The book is part of a series of analyses of global institutions and issues, published by Polity Press. It draws on what we have previously written and presented through various publications and presentations; but also on the work of many other scholars looking at emerging mechanisms of financial governance at the global and regional levels. It seeks to push this literature forward by including in its analysis the democratization of decision-making within the IMF and the development of partnerships between the IMF and other regional and global financial institutions, but most of all by offering recommendations for closing the much-criticized “hypocrisy gap” of the IMF. In contrast to most literature on the IMF, we do not simply focus on the inefficiency of the institution but we consider how to “fix” it by highlighting informal processes of policy formation within the IMF, a critical issue that has not been sufficiently addressed in the literature. There is a possibility for substantial shift in the focus of the IMF through a more developed collaboration with international governance organizations and non-governmental organizations. This could lead to better performance by the IMF in its traditionally mandated areas and the inclusion of social outcomes in its policy formulation. This shift could create a synergy between the IMF and emerging countries. This is one of the possibilities following the institutional arrangements after the 2008 economic crisis. The other side of the coin would see an entrenchment of the influence of the most powerful states, and especially of the United States, the only member state enjoying single-handed veto power. Institutional memory would then participate in pushing the IMF further into what it has traditionally been: an insular community of macroeconomists far removed from local dynamics.
While writing this book, we have attempted through conferences and publications to increase the interest of scholars and students alike in global financial arrangements and the challenges ahead for the IMF. We have both published extensively on the IMF; on the drivers of change within the IMF, on its policies in specific countries, on emerging regional financial mechanisms, and on the possibility of reform of the Fund. This book is not our first collaboration but it is the most significant one. Bessma Momani’s interest in the IMF and global financial governance stemmed from her background in international political economy (IPE) and her analysis of IMF–Egyptian negotiations of the 1990s while a doctoral student at Western University. Bessma teaches courses on the IMF and on IPE at the University of Waterloo and the Balsillie School of International Affairs, and she has consulted for the IMF and its Independent Evaluation Office. She is also a non-resident senior fellow at Brookings Institution and the Centre for International Governance Innovation. Mark Hibben’s PhD thesis at Syracuse University addressed reform of the IMF in the “post-Washington Consensus.” His current research interests are in the politics of development in the “post-Washington Consensus,” with a consideration of the discourses on inequality and how Keynesianism shapes the policy choices of the IMF and the World Bank. The collaboration between the two Bretton Woods organizations and its impact on development outcomes is also one of his areas of interest. Mark teaches political science at St. Joseph’s College of Maine, Standish. Bessma was the external examiner at Mark’s PhD dissertation defense at Syracuse University and since then they have published and presented together on IMF reform.
What’s Wrong with the IMF and How to Fix It is the result of a close collaboration, with each author contributing to every chapter. Bessma Momani is the main author of chapters 2, 3, 6, 7, and 9 while Mark Hibben is the main author of chapters 1, 4, 5, 8, and 10. But this book, from its inception to publication, is the fruit of equal effort from both authors and teachers, interested in pushing forward the debate over IMF reform. It is targeted at students, scholars, IMF experts, and a general audience. With its two distinct parts, “Diagnosing the Ills” and “Finding a Cure,” What’s Wrong with the IMF is a must-have for all those interested in global financial regulation and the challenges ahead for the IMF.
As we reflect on the completion of this book, we are humbled by the “village” of colleagues, IMF staff and administration, institutional support, and family that ultimately made this project possible. Many thanks first to various colleagues who provided feedback on chapters in the book. Specifically, thanks to Anton Malkin, Skylar Brooks, Dustyn Lanz, and Eric Helleiner, who have previously co-authored work with Bessma Momani that has been featured in the book. Particularly invaluable to the project was the difficult editing and indexing work undertaken by doctoral candidate Ousmane Diallo.
IMF staff and administration also were extremely generous with time and access. Special thanks to IMF archivist Premela Isaac and staff in the IMF’s communication department, including Marjorie Henriquez and Jeremy Marks. Thank you also to staff from multiple departments who gave us time and were willing to provide frank assessment of the IMF’s strengths and weaknesses. Thanks to the Independent Evaluation Office’s Miguel de Las Casas for input on a number of chapters, although we may continue to have different takes on some issues. Financial and moral support also came from our home institutions, the University of Waterloo, Balsillie School of International Affairs, and Saint Joseph’s College of Maine. Bessma would like to acknowledge that research for this book was supported by the Social Science and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Finally, the patience of our families and partners was the final foundational piece that allowed us to focus our efforts and push through to completion.
The full meaning of abbreviations is explained when they are first mentioned in the book. After that, acronyms are exclusively used except for very common terms such as “United States” or “United Kingdom.”
ADB | Asian Development Bank |
AfDB | African Development Bank |
AFRITAC | Africa Regional Technical Assistance Center |
AIIB | Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank |
AML/CFT | anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism |
ATI | Africa Training Institute |
BIS | Bank for International Settlements |
BRICS | Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa |
BTC | Joint Regional Training Center for Latin America in Brazil |
CCB | Committee on Capacity Building |
CD | capacity development |
CSO | civil society organization |
CTP | Joint China–IMF Training Program |
ECB | European Central Bank |
ECF | Extended Credit Facility |
ED | executive director |
EFF | Extended Fund Facility |
e-GDDS | Enhanced General Data Dissemination System |
EP | Economist Program |
ESAF | Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility |
EU | European Union |
EURODAD | European Network on Debt and Development |
EWE | Early Warning Exercise |
EWG | Early Warning Group |
FCL | Flexible Credit Line |
FDI | foreign direct investment |
FfD | Financing for Development |
FM | Fiscal Monitor |
FSAP | Financial Sector Assessment Program |
FSB | Financial Stability Board |
FSF | Financial Stability Forum |
FY | Fiscal Year |
G7 | Group of Seven |
G10 | Group of Ten |
G20 | Group of Twenty |
GAB | General Agreements to Borrow |
GATT | General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade |
GDDS | General Data Dissemination System |
GDP | gross domestic product |
GFSR | Global Financial Stability Report |
HIPC | Heavily Indebted Poor Countries |
IBRD | International Bank for Reconstruction and Development |
ICD | Institute for Capacity Development |
ICU | International Clearing Union |
IDA | International Development Association |
IEO | Independent Evaluation Office |
IET | Internal Economics Training |
IFC | International Finance Corporation |
IGN | Interim Guidance Note |
IGO | intergovernmental organization |
IMF | International Monetary Fund |
IMFC | International Monetary and Financial Committee |
IO | international organization |
ISI | import substitution industrialization |
JMAP | Joint Management Action Plan |
JPA | Joint Partnership for Africa |
JSAN | Joint Staff Advisory Note |
JVI | Joint Vienna Institute |
LIC | low-income country |
LIDC | low-income developing country |
LOI | letter of intent |
MAP | Mutual Assessment Process |
MD | managing director |
MDG | Millennium Development Goal |
MDRI | Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative |
MEFP | Memoranda of Economic and Financial Policies |
MOOC | massive open online course |
NAB | New Arrangements to Borrow |
NGO | non-governmental organization |
OBOR | One Belt, One Road |
OECD | Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development |
PFP | policy framework paper |
PLL | Precautionary and Liquidity Line |
PRGF | Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility |
PRS | Poverty Reduction Strategy |
PRSP | Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper |
PSI | Policy Support Instrument |
QPC | quantitative performance criteria |
RCF | Rapid Credit Facility |
RFI | Rapid Financing Instrument |
ROSCs | Reports on the Observance of Standards and Codes |
RSN | Regional Strategy Note |
RTAC | regional technical assistance center |
RTC | regional training center |
RTP | regional training program |
SAF | Structural Adjustment Facility |
SARTTAC | South Asia Regional Training and Technical Assistance Center |
SBA | Stand-By Arrangement |
SCAV | Standing Committee on the Assessment of Vulnerabilities |
SCBR | Standing Committee on Budget and Resources |
SCF | Standby Credit Facility |
SCSI | Standing Committee on Standards Implementation |
SCSRC | Standing Committee on Supervisory and Regulatory Cooperation |
SDDS | Special Data Dissemination Standard |
SDG | Sustainable Development Goal |
SDR | Special Drawing Right |
SIFI | Systemically Important Financial Institution |
STI | IMF–Singapore Regional Training Institute |
TA | technical assistance |
TAIMS | Technical Assistance Information Management System |
UK | United Kingdom |
UKIP | United Kingdom Independence Party |
UN | United Nations |
UNSC | United Nations Security Council |
US, USA | United States, United States of America |
USSR | Union of Soviet Socialist Republics |
WEO | World Economic Outlook |