Cover Page

ANTISEPSIS, DISINFECTION, AND STERILIZATION

TYPES, ACTION, AND RESISTANCE

GERALD E. McDONNELL, B.SC., PH.D.

Vice President of Research and EMEA Affairs

STERIS Limited

Basingstoke, Hampshire, United Kingdom

images

Dedicated to the memory of Professor A. Denver Russell

PREFACE

The control of microorganisms and microbial growth is an important consideration in medical, veterinary, dental, industrial, pharmaceutical, environmental, and food processing settings. This book has been developed to provide a basic understanding of the various chemical and physical antisepsis, disinfection, and sterilization methods used for infection prevention and contamination control. Disinfection and sterilization technologies are used for the control of microorganisms on surfaces, in products, or in air, while antisepsis is particularly associated with microbial reduction on the skin or mucous membranes. These varied applications play important roles in our daily lives, including the provision of safe drinking water, production and preservation of products, sterilization of medical devices, and decontamination of surfaces. The benefits of microbial control have been appreciated since ancient times—for example, in the use of heating, salts, and metals for preservation and wound treatment—despite the absence of any pure understanding of microbiology. Over the last 200 years, we have gained a greater appreciation of microorganisms and their roles in contamination and infection. In parallel, various chemical (referred to as “biocidal”) and physical antisepsis, disinfection, and sterilization methods have been developed and are widely used to render surfaces and products safe for use. Despite these advancements, microbial control issues continue to challenge us. Recent examples include the aftermath of the bioterrorism attacks in the United States; the alarming spread of viral and reemerging bacterial infections such as influenza viruses and tuberculosis, respectively; the more recent identification of newer infectious agents (notably prions and viroids); and the continuing concern of anti-infective (including antibiotic)-resistant microorganisms in hospitals and the general community.

As a background to this subject, an introduction to microbiology is provided, including a discussion of the spectrum of action, determination of efficacy, and common variables that affect the performance of antisepsis, disinfection, and sterilization methods. Disinfection and sterilization are considered as either chemical (biocide) or physical technologies. Chemical biocides include aldehydes, halogens, and phenolics, while physical processes include the use of heat, filtration, and radiation. For each biocide class or process, the various types are discussed, along with their applications, spectrum of activity, advantages, and disadvantages and a brief description of their modes of action. A wider range of methods is used for disinfection and antisepsis applications. Many of these are required to reduce the number of microorganisms, or even the number of certain types of microorganisms, to an acceptable level. In contrast, only a limited number of technologies are utilized for sterilization, which has the ultimate goal of rendering a surface, area, or substance free of all viable microbial contamination. For this reason, disinfection and sterilization methods are considered separately, with a specific chapter dedicated to the various biocides used as antiseptics and in antisepsis applications.

The current understanding of the mechanisms of biocidal action on microorganisms is considered. In most cases, the modes of action of biocides are quite distinct from the more specific mechanisms of action described for anti-infective agents such as antibiotics and antiviral agents. Most biocides demonstrate a wider range of antimicrobial activity, generally corresponding to nonspecific and varied modes of action. The mechanisms of action of biocides are considered in four general categories: oxidizing agents, cross-linking agents, agents that act by transfer of energy, and other structure-disrupting agents. Despite these general mechanisms, some biocides have been shown to have primary targets similar to those of certain antibiotics, and a better understanding of their mechanisms of action is of interest in the development of the next generation of anti-infectives.

Microorganisms demonstrate various natural (intrinsic) and acquired mechanisms to resist the biocidal effects of chemical and physical processes. These mechanisms are also discussed and are important to consider in order to ensure the safe and effective use of biocides and biocidal processes. This topic has been particularly highlighted with the development of resistance to widely used anti-infectives (notably antibiotic-resistant bacteria), but similar mechanisms in microbial resistance to biocides and biocidal processes have been described. Biocide resistance in bacteria has been studied in some detail, with many examples of intrinsic and acquired mechanisms of resistance. Intrinsic mechanisms include biofilm formation and the development of dormant endospores. Acquired resistance mechanisms due to mutations and the acquisition of plasmids, not unlike those described for antibiotics, have also been described. Although many of these mechanisms allow for tolerance in the presence of biocides only at normally inhibitory levels, other mechanisms have been shown to dramatically change the response of a microorganism to biocides and to enable it to survive highly toxic conditions. Although less studied, specific mechanisms of resistance in viruses, prions, and fungi and other eukaryotes are also described.

Overall, it is intended that this book will give a basic understanding of and reference for the various types, modes of action, and mechanisms of resistance of antiseptics, disinfectants, and sterilants for students of microbiology, chemistry, infection control, contamination control, public health, and manufacturing. A greater understanding and appreciation of these technologies will ensure their long-term safe and effective use in contamination and infection prevention.

Acknowledgments

I greatly appreciate the many colleagues and friends who reviewed selected chapters of this book, as well as my wife, Lesley, for her encouragement.

GERALD E. MCDONNELL
Basingstoke, Hampshire, United Kingdom

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Gerald E. McDonnell received a B.Sc. degree in medical laboratory sciences from the University of Ulster (1989) and a Ph.D. in microbial genetics at the Department of Genetics, Trinity College, University of Dublin (1992). His graduate work involved studies on the control of gene expression in Bacillus subtilis. He spent 3 years at the Mycobacterial Research Laboratories, Colorado State University, investigating the mechanisms of antibiotic resistance and cell wall biosynthesis in mycobacteria. In 1995 he joined the St. Louis, Mo., operations of ConvaTec, a division of Bristol-Myers Squibb, as a group leader in microbiology in the research and development of skin care, hard surface disinfection, and cleaning chemistries. He then joined STERIS Corporation and has worked for STERIS for more than 10 years in the United States and in the company’s European, Middle East, and Africa (EMEA) region on the development, research, and support of infection and contamination prevention products and services, including cleaning, antisepsis, disinfection, and sterilization. Dr. McDonnell is currently the vice president of research and EMEA affairs for STERIS, based at its facility in Basingstoke, United Kingdom. He is responsible for the development and support of decontamination processes and services, and he provides training on various aspects of decontamination and contamination control. His basic research interests include infection prevention, decontamination microbiology, emerging pathogens, and modes of action and resistance to biocides. His work also includes the development and implementation of international and national guidance and standards in decontamination. He has published widely in peer-reviewed journals and books, has been granted patents in decontamination technologies, and frequently gives presentations on various aspects of his work at scientific meetings around the world.

IMPORTANT NOTICE

The author has taken great care to confirm the accuracy of the information presented in this book, based on peer-reviewed publications at the time of preparation. However, the author and publisher make no warranty, expressed or implied, that the information in this book is accurate or appropriate for any particular facility, environment, or individual situation, and they are not responsible for any consequences of application of any of the information in this book by any reader. The inclusion of specific products, instruments, reagents, or methods does not represent any endorsement by the American Society for Microbiology, ASM Press, or the author. Nor does the inclusion or inadvertent exclusion of any product, instrument, reagent, or method reflect a preference for any product over other similar competitive products. The comments included in this book are strictly those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of his employer. Some of the products, tests, methods, and applications discussed in this book have particular U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) approval for selective uses; further specific approvals or exclusions may also apply to other international regulatory agencies within specific geographic areas or countries. It is the responsibility of the reader to ensure the necessary local approval status of any product or process that is considered for use in his or her particular hospital, industrial, environmental, or private setting or practice.