China Today series
Richard P. Appelbaum, Cong Cao, Xueying Han, Rachel Parker & Denis Simon, Innovation in China
Greg Austin, Cyber Policy in China
Yanjie Bian, Guanxi: How China Works
Adam Yuet Chau, Religion in China
Jeroen de Kloet and Anthony Y. H. Fung, Youth Cultures in China
Steven M. Goldstein, China and Taiwan
David S. G. Goodman, Class in Contemporary China
Stuart Harris, China's Foreign Policy
William R. Jankowiak and Robert L. Moore, Family Life in China
Elaine Jeffreys with Haiqing Yu, Sex in China
Michael Keane, Creative Industries in China
Joe C. B. Leung and Yuebin Xu, China's Social Welfare
Hongmei Li, Advertising and Consumer Culture in China
Orna Naftali, Children in China
Eva Pils, Human Rights in China
Pitman B. Potter, China's Legal System
Pun Ngai, Migrant Labor in China
Xuefei Ren, Urban China
Nancy E. Riley, Population in China
Janette Ryan, Education in China
Judith Shapiro, China's Environmental Challenges 2nd edition
Alvin Y. So and Yin-wah Chu, The Global Rise of China
Teresa Wright, Party and State in Post-Mao China
Teresa Wright, Popular Protest in China
Jie Yang, Mental Health in China
You Ji, China's Military Transformation
LiAnne Yu, Consumption in China
Xiaowei Zang, Ethnicity in China
polity
Copyright © Yanjie Bian 2019
The right of Yanjie Bian to be identified as Author of this Work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
First published in 2019 by Polity Press
Polity Press
65 Bridge Street
Cambridge CB2 1UR, UK
Polity Press
101 Station Landing
Suite 300
Medford, MA 02155, USA
All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purpose of criticism and review, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher.
ISBN-13: 978-1-5095-0038-3
ISBN-13: 978-1-5095-0039-0 (pb)
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Typeset in 11.5 on 15 pt Adobe Jenson Pro by Toppan Best-set Premedia Limited
Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon
The publisher has used its best endeavours to ensure that the URLs for external websites referred to in this book are correct and active at the time of going to press. However, the publisher has no responsibility for the websites and can make no guarantee that a site will remain live or that the content is or will remain appropriate.
Every effort has been made to trace all copyright holders, but if any have been overlooked the publisher will be pleased to include any necessary credits in any subsequent reprint or edition.
For further information on Polity, visit our website: politybooks.com
To Nan Lin
My Teacher, Doctoral Advisor, and Lifelong Mentor
1894-5 | First Sino-Japanese War |
1911 | Fall of the Qing dynasty |
1912 | Republic of China established under Sun Yat-sen |
1927 | Split between Nationalists (KMT) and Communists (CCP); civil war begins |
1934–5 | CCP under Mao Zedong evades KMT in Long March |
December 1937 | Nanjing Massacre |
1937–45 | Second Sino-Japanese War |
1944 | Publication of “The Chinese Concepts of ‘Face’” by Hsien Chin Hu, with first appearance of notion of guanxi in an English-language publication |
1945–9 | Civil war between KMT and CCP resumes |
1947 | Publication of 《乡土中国》(xiangtu zhongguo, whose English translation From the Soil: The Foundations of Chinese Society was published in 1992)by Fei Xiaotong, with his theory of the mode of differential associations (差序格局, chaxu geju), a social network approach to Chinese social structure |
1949 | Publication of 《中国文化要义》(zhongguo wenhua yaoyi, The Essential Meanings of Chinese Culture) by Liang Shuming, theorizing centrality of guanxi in Chinese culture and society |
October 1949 | KMT retreats to Taiwan; Mao founds People's Republic of China (PRC) |
1950–3 | Korean War |
1952 | Abolition of sociology as an academic discipline |
1953–7 | First Five-Year Plan; PRC adopts Soviet-style economic planning |
1953 | Publication of Fabric of Chinese Society by Morton Fried, first social science monograph on observational research of guanxi by a social scientist of non-Chinese origin |
1954 | First constitution of the PRC and first meeting of the National People's Congress |
1956–7 | Hundred Flowers Movement, a brief period of open political debate |
1957 | Anti-Rightist Movement |
1958–60 | Great Leap Forward, an effort to transform China through rapid industrialization and collectivization |
March 1959 | Tibetan Uprising in Lhasa; Dalai Lama flees to India |
1959–61 | Three Hard Years, widespread famine with tens of millions of deaths |
1960 | Sino-Soviet split |
1962 | Sino-Indian War |
October 1964 | First PRC atomic bomb detonation |
1966–76 | Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution; Mao reasserts power |
February 1972 | President Richard Nixon visits China; “Shanghai Communiqué” pledges to normalize US–China relations |
September 1976 | Death of Mao Zedong |
October 1976 | Ultra-leftist Gang of Four arrested and sentenced |
December 1978 | Deng Xiaoping assumes power; launches Four Modernizations and economic reforms |
1978 | One-child family planning policy introduced |
1979 | US and China establish formal diplomatic ties; Deng Xiaoping visits Washington |
1979 | PRC sends troops to Vietnam |
March 1979 | Restoration of sociology as an academic discipline; reestablishment of Chinese Sociological Association |
February 1981 | Nankai University Class of Sociology opened as year-long course in sociology, with Peter Blau, Fei Xiaotong, and Nan Lin, among others, teaching sociology and social network analysis for first time since restoration of sociology in China |
1982 | Census reports PRC population at more than one billion |
December 1984 | Margaret Thatcher co-signs Sino-British Joint Declaration agreeing to return Hong Kong to China in 1997 |
1989 | Tiananmen Square protests culminate in June 4 military crackdown |
1992 | Deng Xiaoping's Southern Inspection Tour reenergizes economic reforms |
1993–2002 | Jiang Zemin becomes president of PRC; continues economic growth agenda |
1999 | First wave of Job-Search Networks Survey (JSNET Project) conducted to collect data on guanxi and occupational attainment |
November 2001 | World Trade Organization (WTO) accepts China as member |
2002–12 | Hu Jintao, General-Secretary CCP (and President of PRC 2003–13) |
2002–3 | SARS outbreak concentrated in PRC and Hong Kong |
2003 | Chinese General Social Survey series began |
2006 | PRC supplants US as largest CO2 emitter |
August 2008 | Summer Olympic Games in Beijing |
2009 | Second wave of JSNET Project conducted |
2010 | Shanghai World Exposition |
2012 | Xi Jinping appointed General-Secretary of the CCP (and President of PRC from 2013) |
2014–16 | Third wave of JSNET Project conducted as a two-year panel study |
2015 | China abolishes one child policy |
2017 | Xi Jinping reappointed General-Secretary of the CCP's Central Committee (and President of PRC from 2018) |
2018 | National People's Congress removes two-term limit on China's Presidency |
This book is about the social logic of how China works. The focus of analysis is on guanxi, the Chinese expression of personalized social relations. Personal and social relations are important in every culture and society because people live and work in the contexts of these relations. In Western countries, for example, it is common for people to have close personal relations while keeping social relations at a certain distance. In China, however, social relations may not matter much unless and until they are personalized to become part of a focal individual's guanxi network. You get a good job through your guanxi contacts. You start a new business with the money borrowed from and the business contract extended by your guanxi contacts. You manage an organization and sustain it through your guanxi networks of diverse ties. You are both ambitious and competent, and you are a big achiever in the job you do. But you may not get promoted to positions of higher rank or elected into prestigious societies of national honor without mobilizing your guanxi ties to help. Even filing a lawsuit or doing a legal job cannot be free of the underlying social logic of guanxi favoritism.
This book has grown out of my long interest in guanxi scholarship. Growing up in China, I lived in a guanxi culture. But this does not mean I automatically understood the nature of guanxi favoritism, or that I could uncover the internal and external logics of prevalent guanxi influence without adequate academic training. This training started with my reading of Fei Xiaotong's pre-1949 works when I was a college student in China in 1978–81. I gained a more systematic training in social network analysis (SNA) when I engaged in doctoral and postdoctoral research in the United States from 1985 to 1991. A SNA seminar with Nan Lin in my second year of doctoral study enlightened me, planting the scholarly seed of my research interest in guanxi as social exchange networks. Nan's teaching, his one-on-one coaching, his supervising of my dissertation, and his continuous mentoring during my postdoctoral career have been instrumental to my growth from a young student to a learned scholar about guanxi and social networks. This book is dedicated to Nan, my lifelong mentor.
A few other great scholars have each made a unique impact on my guanxi research. At Nankai University in 1981, Fei Xiaotong taught me and my classmates in a sociology class that marked the restoration of sociology to the Chinese college curriculum after its elimination in 1952. Fei's theory of the “mode of differential associations” gave me my first ever view of the centrality of guanxi in Chinese social structure. Andrew Walder, a senior colleague of mine when we both taught at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology during 1997–2001, showed me how to study China in sociological perspective; his concept of “instrumental particular ties” uncovered the theoretical nature of guanxi practices in Mao's and the post-Mao era. The works of Mayfair Yang and Yunxiang Yan, two influential social anthropologists on guanxi scholarship, have directed my attention to both the complex cultural meanings of guanxi and the resilience of guanxi norms in China under reform; I benefited from their comments on my work, and I enjoyed our personal conversations as well as scholarly exchanges at and outside of academic conferences. Finally, Ron Burt, a SNA authority, and Nancy DiTomaso, a well-known sociologist of racial stratification, have each made a remarkable contribution to my rethinking of guanxi. Ron's definition of guanxi as a network structure and his original research on “event contacts” are a showcase of how the study of guanxi networks can enrich the SNA knowledge system. Nancy has urged me to compare guanxi in China to social capital in the US, and her insistence that “these are essentially the same thing” has left a deep mark in my mind when conceptualizing guanxi and social capital. I've enjoyed and will continue to enjoy my collaboration with each of them.
Jonathan Skerrett at Polity Press has been a strong force and support behind this book. He approached me for this book project and waited, long before I was convinced and available to write it for Polity's China Today series. Like other books in the series, this one is intended as a small text for college and postgraduate courses on China. For me, this book is actually a half-and-half product: one half of the book is on my original research and the other half a summary of theoretical and empirical materials from other guanxi researchers. Given the limited space, I have chosen to discuss the prevalence and the increasing significance of guanxi favoritism in the social, economic, political, and legal spheres in China under reform, leaving other topics unattended to. I've made an effort to present quantitative materials in a way that can be understood and appreciated by readers without much quantitative training. A number of more detailed statistical tables can be found online at the book's webpage on www.politybooks.com/guanxi. I'm grateful for Jonathan's patience as well as for the useful comments of two anonymous reviewers he invited on my behalf to evaluate an earlier draft.
I'm grateful also for many collaborators and participants in the survey projects I've conducted since 1997, and a good deal of data from these projects is presented in this book. Deborah Davis and Shaoguang Wang were my collaborators on a 1997–2000 project, sponsored by the Henry Luce Foundation, on urban consumers and material culture in Chinese cities; this project was the first opportunity to measure Chinese New Year visitor networks and social eating networks, which are discussed in chapter 2. The main participants in this project included Wang Hui (who passed away in 2017 at the age of 87) and Guan Ying in Tianjin, Lu Hanlong and Li Yu in Shanghai, Liu Xin and Wang Tie in Wuhan, and Song Ding, Xu Daowen, and Yi Songguo in Shenzhen. A grant from the Hong Kong Research Grants Council (HKUST6052/98H) funded my first Job-Search Network (JSNET) survey project in 1998–9, and a number of grants from China (11AZD022, 13&ZD177) financed subsequent data collections of the JSNET project in 2009, 2014, and 2016. The JSNET project is heavily used in this book, especially in chapter 3; the key collaborators in the project were Liu Shaojie and Wang Wenbin in Changchun, Zhang Wenhong in Tianjin and Shanghai, Bai Hongguang, Guan Xinping, and Mi Shu in Tianjin, Lin Juren and Wu Yuxiao in Jinan, Li Yu in Shanghai, Qiu Haixiong and Liang Yucheng in Guangzhou, Hu Rong and Gong Wenjuan in Xiamen, Feng Shiping and Li Huai in Lanzhou, and Li Liming, Yang Jianke, Zhang Shun, and Zhao Wenlong in Xi’an. My formal and current doctoral advisees Cheng Cheng, Guo Xiaoxian, Hao Mingsong, Huang Xianbi, Li Yinghui, Lu Qiang, Quan Xiaojuan, Sun Yu, Xiao Yang, Yang Yang, and Zhang Lei prepared datasets and many statistical tables and figures presented in this book and on the webpage, and Zhang Yixue provided technical assistance with the bibliography.
My special thanks are due to my wife Qinghong for her love and companionship. As always, she is the first listener to my “presentation” of ideas in rough form at home. Her reactions are as important as her personal reflections on Chinese life. I'm also grateful to my sons Peter and John, as well as their significant others Linda and Kayoko, respectively, for their emotional support. To them, Dad is always working and not making much time for the family. After this book, is a change expected? They may still wonder.
I thank Polity Press editors for their professional assistance. Jonathan Skerrett, once again, worked with me on my first drafts, offering highly useful comments on the narratives of each chapter as well as specific suggestions on the presentation of quantitative materials. Fiona Sewell provided thorough and diligent copyediting, and her effort has improved the exposition of this book. And others at Polity Press have been a source of advice and help at various stages of this book's production.
The main contents of this book were written and revised while I was taking my sabbatical leave from the University of Minnesota and residing at Xi’an Jiaotong University during the academic year of 2017–18. I'm grateful to both institutions for their support in many different ways.
Yanjie Bian
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
November 10, 2018
bianx001@umn.edu