Cover Page

Operationalizing Sustainability

Pierre Massotte

Patrick Corsi

images

“An outstanding advance in foresight methodology.”

Dr. Thierry GAUDIN
http://gaudin.org

Member of the Club of Rome–Brussels
Honorary Member of the Club of Budapest–Paris

Founder and President of “Prospective 2100”, a World Foresight Association
http://2100.org
Member of the Board of the World Futures Studies Federation
www.wfsf.org
One of the four founders of the six countries
Program on Innovation Policies
6cp.net

Note to all Contributors

Sustainability isn’t really a new topic!

Humanity has faced this concept for many years. Yet, so far, the scope covered by the term “sustainability” hasn’t been very wide, even if, in a sense, its “soul” was present. As an example, both within IBM and École des Mines, we used to present sustainability by introducing such names as “global quality” or “global optimization, etc. This was done while conducting sustainability actions and sometimes without the measuring the actual range of our contribution, either at the social or ecological level. Could we possibly have these kinds of pioneers?

The answer is no. Actually, any evolution, even in advanced technological fields, is based on stepwise jumps, which may bear the names of mutation, self-organization or adaptation. Even when considering a paradigm change, the fundamental roots of evolution remain the same and any process remains but a process.

To reinforce our working baseline, experiences and assets within the sustainability subject matter, we have opted for grounding the proposed approach on examples, test cases, results and skills, all gained everywhere over several decades.

In preparing and launching this book (in twinned operations with its companion book Sustainability Calling [MAS 15b] during a sustained period of more than four years over 2011–2015), we strived to create the present original synthesis from the sum of information that we collected, with the view to elaborate a technology suited to an actual and current sustainability concept.

However, a smaller fraction of the contributing elements may originate from authors unidentified to us. Or possibly, of whom we involuntarily lost trace of the names. All authors explicitly mentioned in the two bibliographies, and those who may perhaps not appear as well, certainly contributed either directly or indirectly to the development of an emerging “sustainability science. Furthermore, creating an exhaustive account of sustainability topics is a daunting endeavor, which would likely require an entire library, if not simply an impossible task to achieve. While we wish to express our sincere gratitude to each and every one of the diverse authors for having enlightened us and for their useful contribution to this necessary and promising field, we therefore remain candidly apologetic for our any possible oversight resulting from these omissions.

Note to the Reader

Sustainability is a keyword. We were happy to build a plane that is sustainable in terms of energy. We could also make life in the cockpit sustainable, as well as for a human being. And this, we didn’t know if it was possible”.

André Borshberg, Solar Impulse pilot, upon landing in Hawaii on July 3rd 2015 at sunrise, after a nonstop 5 days and 5 nights solar energy flight from Nagoya, Japan [SOL 15].

images

The ten principles of the UN Global Compact (UN Advisory Board, July 26th, 2000)

Will mankind one day secure a guide to a sustainable world? This book is an attempt. Like solar impulse and other far-fetched dreams, only attempts, trials and feedback can pave the new way. Although we share a definite clarity about this ultimate aim, steering the way through a highly complex world is not easy. Only smaller steps can be proposed to decision makers for the time being.

There exists by now a real concern for the life-sustaining capacities of the Earth. If only in the realm of climate change, the international Kyoto Protocol 1997 treaty slowly came into force for a number of countries in 2005. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) proceedings now include the 2015 Paris COP21 Climate Change Conference. Yet, the concern is of an encompassing nature and it is called by one word only: sustainability.

The present book is the complementary book to Sustainability Calling: Underpinning Technologies, by the same authors and publishing houses (published in September 2015) [MAS 15b].

For a comprehensive understanding of the foundations of sustainability, it is recommended to first read the above book, which provides the models, methods and tools to investigate and tackle the deeper notion of sustainability in a strategic way. However, the present book implements the ways to make sustainability operational and attempts at measuring it and, for practitioners, can be read without the first one. Together, the two books constitute a comprehensive treaty on sustainability for a variety of academic and executive readers in all walks of post-modern activities.

In Sustainability Calling: Underpinning Technologies, the authors discuss the mechanisms underlying sustainability and the principles to take into account to define its technologies (in the etymological sense), even if and when the aggregation and integration of these principles and mechanisms can not be done yet with presently available technology.

The objective of the present book is to exhibit an attempt of unification, based on these concepts, one that is implementable. The tactical part about sustainability implementation and operationalization (the “how to do”) is also meant to discover, suggest and develop new practical elements about a future method. The authors attempt to answer the issues of main importance; yet an exhaustive account necessitates at least three times the volume of this book. It provides a mind-centered roadmap on how sustainability must be addressed in the field and how the measurement of a sustainable system can be performed.

To begin with, the following introduction develops a vision and a process to determine how a question relevant to sustainability can be answered. Let us always keep in mind that sustainability can be investigated as a new science given its specificities.

List of Acronyms

ACPVIAnalyse en Composantes Principales basées sur les Variables Instrumentales (see PCAIV)
AFNORAgence Française de Normalisation
AHTaverage handling time
AIartificial intelligence
AIDSacquired immune deficiency syndrome
ANNsartificial neural networks
ANSIAmerican National Standards Institute
APSadvanced planning and scheduling
ATMasynchronous transfer mode
ASSafter sale service
BAbusiness analytics
BCGBoston Consulting Group (Strategy)
BCIbrain–computer interface
BFIbig factors inventory
BPRbusiness process engineering
CADcomputer-aided design
CBRcase-based reasoning
CEOChief Executive Officer
CFOChief Finance Officer
CHONcarbon – hydrogen – oxygen – nitrogen
CHPcombined heat and power
CIMcomputer integrated manufacturing
CIOChief Information Officer
CMMcapability maturity model
CRMcustomer relationship management
CSCCorporate Service Corps
CSRcorporate social responsibility collaborative work
CWcompetitive watch
DMSdecision making system
DNAdeoxyribonucleic acid
DSSdecision support system
ECBEuropean Central Bank
EIeconomic intelligence (business intelligence)
EMAÉcole des Mines d’Alès
EPFLÉcole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (Switzerland)
EPREinstein–Podolsky-Rosen (thought experiment)
EPTEuropean Patent Office (http://www.epo.org)
ERPenterprise resources planning
EUEuropean Union
FAfunctional analysis
FASTFAST diagram (Function Analysis System Technique)
FFTfast Fourier transform
FLOPSfloating-point operations per second
FRfunctional requirements (functional analysis)
GCIglobal competitiveness index
GDPgross domestic product
HECHautes Etudes Commerciales
HPHewlett-Packard
HMSholonic manufacturing system
IBMinternational business machines
ICTinformation and communication technologies
IDEF0Icam definition for function modeling
IKBinnovation knowledge base
IMFInternational Monetary Fund
IMSIntelligent Manufacturing System (European initiative)
INRAInstitut National de la Recherche Agronomique (France)
IPintellectual property
ISCinitial sensitivity conditions ISC Innovation Steering Committee
ISinformation systems
ITinformation technologies
KADSknowledge acquisition and documentation structuring
KBSknowledge-based systems
KDBknowledge data base
KFknowledge fluency
KMknowledge management (management of knowledge and know-how)
KSFkey success factors
LEDlight-emitting diode
LHSleft hand side
LLElocal linear embedding
LOClines of code
MAQmaximum allowable quantity
MESmanufacturing execution system
MIDsmobile internet services
MMOmassively multiplayer online
MTBFmean time between failures
MTTRmean time to repair
NBICNanotechnology – Biotechnology – Information technologies – Cognitive sciences
NFCnear field communication
NGONon-Governmental Organization
NHSNational Health Service
NIHnon-invented here
NIHNational Institute of Health
NLDSnonlinear dynamic systems
NPDnew product development
OBSorganization breakdown structure (functional structure)
OCDobjective costs design
ORoperations research
OTSM-TRIZa general theory of powerful thinking
P2Ppeer-to-peer
PCproduction control/personal computer/personal computing
PCTpatent cooperation treaty (www.wipo.org/pct/)
PCAIVprincipal component analysis based on instrumental variables (see ACPVI)
PERTprogram of evaluation and review technique
PLOOTplant layout optimization
PLCproduct lifecycle
PMIProject Management Institute
PPCpay per call
PPTpay per time
P-TECHpathway in technology
R&Dresearch and development
RASreliability – availability – serviceability
RFIDradio frequency identification
RHSright hand side
RNAribonucleic acid
ROIreturn on investment
RPGrole playing game
RSSreally simple syndication
SAsystem analysis
SADTstructure analysis and design technique
SCEMsupply chain event management
SCIsustainable competitiveness index
SCPsystem controlled by product
SDSsustainable development strategy
SEEAsystem of integrated environmental and economic accounting
SHSsocial and human sciences
SICsensitivity to initial conditions
SMACsocial, mobile, analytics, connected
SMEsmall and medium enterprise
SPQLshipped product quality level
SPSsustainable production system
SSMEservice science, management and engineering
SWstrategic watch
SWOTstrengths, weakness, opportunities and threats (Strategy)
TBCtime-based competitivity
TQMtotal quality management
TTtakt time
TRIZtheory of inventive problem solving (Teoriya Resheniya Izobretatelskikh Zadatch – TRIZ, Russian acronym)
TWtechnology watch
UAVunmanned aerial vehicle (e.g. drones)
UMLunified modeling language
UNUnited Nations
VAvalue analysis
WIPwork in progress
WIPOWorld Intellectual Property Organization (www.wipo.org)
WWWworld wide web

NOTE.– The world “backlog” is often used in the specific manufacturing context and means “equal to all customer of supplier orders received and not yet shipped or delivered” [GRE 87]. Outside this context, a backlog retains its usual meaning of accumulation, supply or arrears.