polity
Copyright © Thomas G. Weiss 2018
The right of Thomas G. Weiss to be identified as Author of this Work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
First published in 2018 by Polity Press
Polity Press
65 Bridge Street
Cambridge CB2 1UR, UK
Polity Press
101 Station Landing, Suite 300
Medford, MA 02155, USA
All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purpose of criticism and review, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher.
ISBN-13: 978-1-5095-1729-9
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Weiss, Thomas G. (Thomas George), 1946- author.
Title: Would the world be better without the UN? / Thomas G. Weiss.
Description: Cambridge, UK ; Malden, MA, USA : Polity Press, [2018] | Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2017019714 (print) | LCCN 2017043448 (ebook) | ISBN 9781509517282 (Mobi) | ISBN 9781509517299 (Epub) | ISBN 9781509517251 | ISBN 9781509517268 (pbk.)
Subjects: LCSH: United Nations. | Security, International--International cooperation. | Peace-building--International cooperation. | Human rights--International cooperation. | Poverty--International cooperation. | Environmental quality--International cooperation.
Classification: LCC JZ4984.5 (ebook) | LCC JZ4984.5 .W4595 2018 (print) | DDC 341.23--dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2017019714
The publisher has used its best endeavours to ensure that the URLs for external websites referred to in this book are correct and active at the time of going to press. However, the publisher has no responsibility for the websites and can make no guarantee that a site will remain live or that the content is or will remain appropriate.
Every effort has been made to trace all copyright holders, but if any have been inadvertently overlooked the publisher will be pleased to include any necessary credits in any subsequent reprint or edition.
For further information on Polity, visit our website: politybooks.com
Thomas G. Weiss is Presidential Professor of Political Science at The City University of New York’s Graduate Center and Director Emeritus (2001–14) of the Ralph Bunche Institute for International Studies who was named 2016 Andrew Carnegie Fellow. Past president of the International Studies Association (2009–10) and recipient of its “IO Distinguished Scholar Award 2016,” he also directed the United Nations Intellectual History Project (1999–2010) and was research professor at SOAS, University of London (2012–15), chair of the Academic Council on the UN System (2006–9), editor of Global Governance, research director of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, research professor at Brown University’s Watson Institute for International Studies, executive director of the Academic Council on the UN System and of the International Peace Academy, a member of the UN secretariat, and a consultant to public and private agencies. He has written extensively about multilateral approaches to international peace and security, humanitarian action, and sustainable development. His most recent single-authored volumes include Humanitarianism Intervention: Ideas in Action (2016); What’s Wrong with the United Nations and How to Fix It (2016); Governing the World? Addressing “Problems without Passports” (2014); Global Governance: Why? What? Whither? (2013); Humanitarian Business (2013); and Thinking about Global Governance: Why People and Ideas Matter (2011).
I begin with my profound gratitude to the Carnegie Corporation of New York, which named me a 2016 Andrew Carnegie Fellow. The generous support provided two years for the kind of research and reflection that I hope is present on every page in this book. Vartan Gregorian was my boss at Brown University and as a consultant to the corporation when he first arrived in New York. But he has become far more than that over the years, inspiring me to push myself and my thoughts about the past, present, and future of multilateralism and the United Nations. Most charitable foundations and governments invest in institutions rather than individuals and in soundbites rather than research. The Carnegie Corporation under his stewardship has gone against that conventional grain, and so other fellows and I have been the beneficiaries. This book would not have appeared as it has, or as quickly, without the foundation’s generosity of spirit and vision.
The most congenial and productive of my professional homes has, since 1998, been The City University of New York’s Graduate Center. Former president William Kelly hired me when he was provost and consistently and enthusiastically supported my professional activities as well as tolerated my sense of humor. Current president Chase Robinson has continued to build the distinction of the Graduate Center and nominated me to be a Carnegie Fellow, which has made possible a wonderfully rich last two years.
I have benefited over the years from a number of wonderful intellects and helping hands among my advanced graduate students. This volume reflects research by Paul Celentano, who helped fill in some of the holes that existed after I formulated the book outline. Danielle Zach, as she has over the last decade, abandoned her own work as a post-doc to apply a sharp mind and eye to the raw manuscript, improving substantially its structure and content. This book simply would not have been as timely or persuasive without Paul’s and Danielle’s able helping hands.
This volume marks the culmination of career-long efforts, and I repeat a bit of what I wrote in a 2011 collection of essays.1 What has united, or perhaps haunted, my work over the years is what many would deem a curious conviction – namely, that community interests should hold sway but are invariably shortchanged, nationally or internationally. Long before the “America First” of Donald Trump in the United States, the country’s welfare had often been sacrificed on the altar of individualism; but globally those of the commons are typically and tragically trampled by great powers as well as by tin-pot dictators and megalomaniacs. Yet, I have remained steadfast in believing that multilateral cooperation is a way not only to attenuate American and big-power arrogance but also to solve many, albeit not all, thorny problems that defy national boundaries.
My analyses of contemporary world politics might very well “depress Dr Pangloss,” the character in Voltaire’s Candide who believes that all is for the best in this best of all possible worlds. The gaps are enormous between what happens in the world polis and what is on the books – spelled out in the UN Charter and hundreds of international treaties, as well as in public statements by politicians, pundits, prime ministers, princes, and presidents. Surely, ours cannot be the best of all possible worlds. I remain persuaded that good people and good ideas can make a difference to the quality of both human life and international society.
That optimism needs to be asserted amidst the disturbing populist and inward-looking politics in the West and elsewhere that accompanies the most gut-wrenching humanitarian disaster in recent memory. Our collective conscience apparently was beyond shocking, as a halfmillion Syrians died in real time, including children suffocating from chemical weapons. That said, the bottom line for my last lecture would also resemble that from my first: I’m an inveterate optimist who believes that it is better sometimes to be wrong, rather than a pessimist and always right.
A career in any business, let alone the academy, involves heavy debts accumulated from both deliberate and unintended encounters with too many smart people to mention; but a few nonetheless stand out whose names I would like to register at the outset because much of what follows in these pages draws on collaborative work over the years. I have drawn on joint products and so would like to indicate clearly up front my debt to a number of individuals. I cite our main joint work here and will not repeat them in subsequent chapters, nor will I refer readers to my three previous Polity Press books.2
This book asks an honest question: “Would the World Be Better without the UN?” The answer is “no,” a response that draws on four and a half decades of close encounters of a different (not “third”) kind. I begin with my dear friend and mentor Leon Gordenker, whose own scholarship and unpretentious demeanor have always provided a beacon; as I pulled together the outline and elaborated the manuscript, I became even more fully aware of the extent to which I am indebted to him. Over the years, my remedial education about the world organization has continued through collaboration with David P. Forsythe and Roger A. Coate (and later Kelly-Kate Pease) on eight editions of our UN textbook.3 I have learned much from Sam Daws on two editions of a major handbook about the world body.4 And, on the related topic of global governance and its relationship to the UN, I have always taken away more than I contributed from collaborations with Craig Murphy, Ramesh Thakur, and Rorden Wilkinson.5
I would like to draw attention to my collaboration between 1999 and 2010 with Tatiana Carayannis, Louis Emmerij, and Richard Jolly in the United Nations Intellectual History Project (UNIHP), a long overdue effort to document the world organization’s ideational contribution to economic and social development. The sixteen volumes and oral history are now widely cited, and I am especially pleased with our three “synthesis” volumes whose conclusions penetrate the analysis here.6 Collaboration with Dan Plesch on the UN’s wartime history filled another knowledge gap.7 And research with Stephen Browne helped me return to the development vineyards with the Future UN Development System Project (FUNDS).8
My preoccupation with the humanitarian struggle to protect and help people caught in the cross-hairs of armed violence was formed in collaboration with Larry Minear in directing the Humanitarianism & War Project. Gareth Evans, Michael Ignatieff, and Ramesh Thakur were especially appreciated colleagues during the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (ICISS), which resulted in The Responsibility to Protect (R2P) and an accompanying research volume.9 Peter Hoffman went from my classroom to ICISS to helping to introduce me to the theory of new wars and of new humanitarianisms in two books.10 Finally, Michael Barnett and I worked together on two volumes that seek to re-examine humanitarian shibboleths and rethink standard operating procedures and principles.11
I am deeply grateful that former UN secretary-general Kofi Annan agreed to grace these pages with a foreword. I have known and admired this gracious and dedicated man for the last three decades. The world definitely would be a less kind and safe place without him.
I end by dedicating this volume to the next generation, and more especially to my grandchildren Amara, Kieran, and Grace. They and their peers worldwide deserve a safer and more just planet; and a better United Nations could help make that wish a reality.
TGW
New York, July 2017
The United Nations was born from the ashes of war almost three-quarters of a century ago. Against that backdrop of unimaginable suffering and collapse in basic values, courageous politicians and citizens sought new institutional ways to deal with the life-threatening challenges of the day, and the future.
Ironically, today, as the number of threats has multiplied, the political mood has inexplicably turned inward, seeking to build walls rather than tear them down. Instead of being more central to global problem-solving, in the current climate of nationalism, the UN’s value-based framework and institutions are not only not accepted by everyone but actively under attack.
In a bold and original way, Thomas G. Weiss uses a counterfactual approach to examine what the United Nations does, what would happen if it ceased to exist, and what can be done to improve it. He does not shy away from lamenting the obvious shortcomings and failures of member states and international civil servants; but he also provides a timely reminder of the crucial normative and operational work undertaken by the world organization. He points out that we can await new unspeakable disasters to prove the need for better intergovernmental organizations and undoubtedly be rewarded with unimaginable calamities. Or we can make fitter for purpose the ones that we have.
My own decade at the helm of the UN leads me to salute this book because it helps us to understand the crucial importance of the world organization in tackling the considerable challenges facing the world today. Tom Weiss has engagingly and honestly asked a very tough question found in the book’s title, Would the World Be Better without the UN? His negative reply is an indispensable guide for anyone worried about the future of the planet and of the United Nations.
Kofi A. Annan
Geneva, July 2017
APMBC | Anti-Personnel Mine Ban Convention |
AU | African Union |
BWC | Biological Weapons Convention |
CAR | Central African Republic |
CCW | Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons |
CEDAW | Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women |
CFCs | chlorofluorocarbons |
CHR | Commission on Human Rights |
CIA | Central Intelligence Agency |
CIEC | Conference on International Economic Cooperation |
COP | Conference of Parties |
CWC | Chemical Weapons Convention |
DAC | Development Assistance Committee (OECD) |
DaO | Delivering as One |
DHA | Department of Humanitarian Affairs |
DPKO | Department of Peacekeeping Operations |
DRC | Democratic Republic of the Congo |
ECOSOC | Economic and Social Council |
ECOWAS | Economic Community of West African States |
EOSG | Executive Office of the Secretary-General |
EPTA | Expanded Programme of Technical Assistance |
ERC | Emergency Relief Coordinator |
EU | European Union |
FAO | Food and Agriculture Organization |
FUNDS | Future United Nations Development System Project |
G-7 | Group of 7 |
G-20 | Group of 20 |
G-77 | Group of 77 |
GATT | General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade |
GCC | Gulf Cooperation Council |
GDI | Gender-Related Development Index |
GDP | gross domestic product |
GEM | Gender Empowerment Measure |
GHGs | greenhouse gases |
GNI | gross national income |
GNP | gross national product |
GWOT | global war on terrorism |
HDI | Human Development Index |
HFC | hydrofluorocarbons |
HIPPO | High-Level Independent Panel on Peace Operations |
HIV/AIDS | human immunodeficiency virus infection/acquired immune deficiency syndrome |
HLP | High-Level Panel on Threats, Challenges and Change |
HPG | Humanitarian Policy Group |
HPI | Human Poverty Index |
HRC | Human Rights Council |
IAEA | International Atomic Energy Agency |
IASC | Inter-Agency Standing Committee |
ICC | International Criminal Court |
ICCPR | International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights |
ICESCR | International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights |
ICISS | International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty |
ICJ | International Court of Justice |
ICRC | International Committee of the Red Cross |
ICTR | International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda |
ICTY | International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia |
IDA | International Development Association |
IDP | internally displaced person |
IFAD | International Fund for Agricultural Development |
ILO | International Labour Organization |
IMF | International Monetary Fund |
INSTRAW | International Research and Training Institute for the Advancement of Women |
INTERFET | International Force for East Timor |
IOM | International Organization for Migration |
IPCC | Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change |
ISEP | International Smallpox Eradication Program |
ISG | International Support Group/Iraq Survey Group |
ISIL | Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant |
ITU | International Telecommunication Union |
JCPOA | Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action |
JIU | Joint Inspection Unit |
KFOR | Kosovo Force |
LGBT | lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, and transgender |
MDG | Millennium Development Goal |
MSF | Médecins Sans Frontières [Doctors without Borders] |
NAM | Non-Aligned Movement |
NATO | North Atlantic Treaty Organization |
NGO | nongovernmental organization |
NIEO | new international economic order |
NPT | Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons |
OAS | Organization of American States |
OCHA | Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs |
ODA | official development assistance |
ODI | Overseas Development Institute |
OECD | Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development |
OHCHR | Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights |
OIOS | Office of International Oversight Services |
ONUCA | United Nations Observer Group in Central America |
OPCW | Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons |
OPEC | Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries |
OSCE | Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe |
OWG | open working group |
P-5 | permanent five [members of the Security Council] |
PAHO | Pan American Health Organization |
PBC | Peacebuilding Commission |
PBF | Peacebuilding Fund |
PBSO | Peacebuilding Support Office |
QCPR | quadrennial comprehensive policy review |
R2P | responsibility to protect |
RC | resident coordinator |
RSG | representative of the secretary-general |
SARS | severe acute respiratory syndrome |
SDG | Sustainable Development Goal |
SMG | Senior Management Group |
SNA | system of national accounts |
SOPs | standard operating procedures |
SSDS | System of Social and Demographic Statistics |
SUNFED | Special United Nations Fund for Economic Development |
TNCs | transnational corporations |
UDHR | Universal Declaration of Human Rights |
UNAMIR | United Nations Assistance Mission for Rwanda |
UNCTAD | United Nations Conference on Trade and Development |
UNDOF | United Nations Disengagement Observer Force |
UNDP | United Nations Development Programme |
UNDS | United Nations development system |
UNEF | United Nations Emergency Force |
UNEP | United Nations Environment Programme |
UNEPS | United Nations Emergency Peace Service |
UNESCO | United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization |
UNFCCC | United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change |
UNFPA | United Nations Population Fund |
UNHCR | [Office of the] UN High Commissioner for Refugees |
UNICEF | United Nations Children’s Fund |
UNIFEM | United Nations Development Fund for Women |
UNIHP | United Nations Intellectual History Project |
UNMIK | United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo |
UNMOVIC | United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission |
UNOCI | United Nations Operation in Côte d’Ivoire |
UNRRA | United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration |
UNSCOM | United Nations Special Commission |
UNSO | United Nations Statistical Office |
UNTAET | United Nations Transitional Administration in East Timor |
UNWCC | United Nations War Crimes Commission |
UPR | Universal Periodic Review |
UPU | Universal Postal Union |
WEP | World Employment Programme [ILO] |
WFP | World Food Programme |
WHA | World Health Assembly |
WHO | World Health Organization |
WMD | weapons of mass destruction |
WMO | World Meteorological Organization |
WTO | World Trade Organization |